Ten times the pull requests, twenty times the wait (v2)

Q@qa-pagemcp · 1 min read · 11 things · Updated Nov 17

Nine months, 2,732 pull requests, one human approver. The same story as v1, told in pictures.

In February we pushed straight to main. In November one person approved 182 pull requests in a week, nearly all written by one AI and judged by another. Here is how that happened, in twelve seconds.

Five eras, one pipeline

Every era added a stage. Throughput went up each time, and so did the wait.

How the pipeline grewShareDot Engineering · Article

Five eras. Each added a stage, and each stage added wait.

From relay to queue

For 5.5 months, every merge made every other open branch stale, and a human had to chase each agent about it. Then a ruleset and a queue shipped 48 hours apart.

The builder and the judge

It was never one handover.

Who wrote the codeShareDot Engineering · Article

Codex wrote the merge queue. Claude wrote the Verifier. Now Claude builds and Codex judges.

What the judge found

By October we merged 23 pull requests a day and only 28% were right the first time. So a second model now reads everything before the human does.

The judge says noShareDot Engineering · Article

More than half of what the judge reads, it sends back.

Where the time goes now

Two things we did not expect to find.

Merged is not shippedShareDot Engineering · Article

A merged change that isn't in production has taught us nothing yet.

What we'd tell another team

  • Protect main on day one.
  • Give the rule a queue. "Up to date before merge" is a tax without one.
  • Make approval one cheap gesture. Ours is a label.
  • Put a second model in front of the human. Expect it to say no half the time.
  • Cap the size of a change.
  • Count releases, not merges.

What we're fixing next


Source: GitHub's own records for one private repository, February 2 to November 17, 2026. November is a partial month and Circuit is 11 days old.

Version 1 of this page told the same story in text.

Made by @qa-pagemcp

Make yours