Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes' Exes Get Engaged

Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig — exes of Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes, who married in September — announced their engagement this spring.

@sharedot

Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes' Exes Get Engaged

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Celebrity
  • Engagements
  • Andrew Shue
  • Marilee Fiebig
  • Amy Robach

Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig — exes of Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes, who married in September — announced their engagement this spring.

The Twist Nobody Saw Coming

Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig — the ex-spouses of former "Good Morning America" anchors Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes — announced their engagement in a People interview published October 21.

"We're very grateful and hopeful," Shue, 59, told the outlet. "I don't know how it happened, but there's a happy ending."

How Shue and Fiebig Found Each Other

The unlikely pair began dating in 2023, after their exes' workplace romance was exposed in November 2022. Shue was married to Robach from 2010 to 2023, while Fiebig, an Atlanta-based attorney, married Holmes in 2010 and shares 13-year-old daughter Sabine with him.

Shue told People that he "had to grow through a lot of pain and a lot of struggle and a lot of humility," adding, "I think the magic of love is when you go from a need to giving."

He framed the connection as "freak luck" — a circumstance that let both of them reveal themselves "in a time where we both needed a friend."

Days After Their Exes Quietly Married

The announcement lands just one month after Holmes and Robach tied the knot in a private ceremony in Arkansas on September 19, with the marriage license recorded on October 13, according to USA Today.

The pair had announced their engagement on their "Amy & T.J." podcast in October 2025, and both anchors have denied cheating, saying they were in divorce proceedings when they got together.

Shue and Fiebig's engagement announcement comes a month after their exes' quiet wedding — a coincidence celebrity watchers across outlets were quick to flag.

Experts Say the Bond Isn't So Strange

While the romance raised eyebrows, psychologist Alice Shepard told USA Today that shared trauma often creates fertile ground for connection.

"Trauma affects us in both conscious and unconscious ways," she said, explaining that it can be a relief to find a partner who helps make sense of your experiences without needing words.

Shue echoed the sentiment from his own angle, telling People that the most important project is "building a foundation for your kids and creating a home and showing them a loving relationship they can see and experience."

Why Fans Are Calling It the Ultimate Plot Twist

Outlets from E! News to In Touch framed the news as the surprising final act of a four-year tabloid saga: the anchors who scandalized daytime TV are married, and the spouses they left behind are engaged to each other.

Shue, the "Melrose Place" alum and co-founder of civic initiative The Forum, told People the journey required accepting "my own part in marriage not working out," calling finding Fiebig, 48, "an extraordinary gift."

Page Six reported at the time the pair began dating that "it's bigger than the affair now" because they connected over shared values.

What Comes Next for Both Couples

Meanwhile, Robach, 53, and Holmes, 49, are settling into marriage after their September 19 Arkansas ceremony in Holmes's home state, where he attended the University of Arkansas, per AOL.

With both couples now officially on the record, the saga that began with a Daily Mail photo scandal and ended two GMA3 careers has closed on what Shue himself calls a happy ending — for everyone involved.

Sources

  1. usatoday.com › T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach's exes Andrew Shue, Marilee Fiebig are engaged
  2. yahoo.com › Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig announce engagement after exes Amy Robach, T.J. Holmes' private wedding
  3. eonline.com › Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes' Exes Andrew Shue, Marilee Fiebig Are Engaged
  4. aol.com › Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes' Exes Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig Announce Engagement
  5. intouchweekly.com › Andrew Shue Announces Engagement to Marilee Fiebig After Exes Amy Robach, T.J. Holmes Quietly Marry

More on Celebrity