Anti-Waymo Op-Eds Scored Up to 95% AI-Written
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Automotive
- Autonomous Driving
- Waymo
- AI
Semafor reports that six op-eds opposing Waymo scored 68% to 95% AI-written on Pangram, and none disclosed AI use.
A covert AI campaign against robotaxis
Opponents of Waymo have been placing op-eds in local news outlets arguing the autonomous taxi company could cost jobs, endanger riders, deprive the government of information, and even block fire trucks.
According to Semafor, the AI detection service Pangram found many of the pieces were written with significant AI input, yet none carried a label disclosing AI use.
Ira Goldstein, the former head of New York's Black Car Fund and author of a Daily News op-ed, told Semafor a PR firm prepared the first draft, which he reviewed and edited, saying he stands by every word. Semafor reports the firm later dropped the campaign to work for Waymo itself.
The Pangram scores are striking
Semafor listed Pangram scores for six op-eds across five outlets, ranging from 68% to 95% AI-written.
Per Semafor, two Dallas Morning News pieces by lawyer Amy Witherite scored 95% and 71%; a San Francisco Chronicle piece on robotaxis going dormant during power outages scored 88%; a New York Daily News piece scored 68%; a San Diego Union-Tribune piece on job displacement scored 95%; and a Times of San Diego piece on tracking Waymo's rollout scored 87%.
FourWeekMBA, aggregating Semafor's figures, calculates the median at 87.5%, with four of six pieces scoring 87% or more.
Editors and authors push back differently
The authors and editors named in the report gave divergent accounts.
Goldstein said a PR-firm draft is standard procedure; the Chronicle's Michael Redmond told Semafor he uses AI tools for research and clarity, and Chronicle editor Matt Fleischer said the outlet asks opinion writers to disclose AI use.
Dallas Morning News commentary editor Ryan Sanders said in an email that limited AI use does not disqualify a submission, but 'we don't accept pieces generated entirely by AI.'
Daily News executive editor Andrew Julien said the paper aims to create stricter AI guardrails, citing its litigation against Microsoft and OpenAI, per Semafor. Witherite's spokesperson called AI 'a shiny object' to change the subject.
Why it matters for the robotaxi fight
The op-eds are part of a monthslong battle over whether Waymo can operate commercially in major cities.
Semafor cites Washington Post reporting that the Coalition for Accountability and Road Safety spent more than $2.6 million on ads in the DC area in 2026, more than the winning mayoral candidate spent.
Waymo operates commercially in 15 US cities but faces opposition from labor unions, Uber, Lyft, AI-skeptical groups, and pedestrian safety advocates.
Caveats matter: the scores come from one detection tool, Semafor did not report who organized the campaign as a whole, and its story contains no comment from Waymo. Editors now face pressure to define disclosure rules as AI-written advocacy floods local pages.