CBS Says Jeremiah Smith Slips Out of Heisman Favorite Spot

After Ohio State's 30-18 loss at USC, Jeremiah Smith slipped to third in Heisman odds behind Miami's Darian Mensah and Malachi Toney.

@sharedot

CBS Says Jeremiah Smith Slips Out of Heisman Favorite Spot

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Books
  • College Football
  • Heisman Trophy
  • Jeremiah Smith
  • Ohio State

After Ohio State's 30-18 loss at USC, Jeremiah Smith slipped to third in Heisman odds behind Miami's Darian Mensah and Malachi Toney.

A rainy upset in Los Angeles changed the Heisman race

USC beat No. 2 Ohio State 30-18 at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum on Saturday night, a result ESPN calls the signature win of Lincoln Riley's five-year tenure and one that sent a sold-out crowd storming the field.

For the Books reader following the sport's unfolding narratives, the real story within the story is how one wet night rewrote the season's biggest individual storyline.

The Buckeyes played without starting quarterback Julian Sayin, who suffered a potential season-ending injury two weeks earlier against Indiana, and their offense never found its usual explosiveness.

Yahoo Sports reports Ohio State has now tumbled out of its Top 10 entirely, with Miami taking over the No. 1 spot.

Why Smith's Heisman campaign took the hit

CBS Sports reports that Jeremiah Smith entered the week as the solid Heisman favorite ahead of Miami's duo of Darian Mensah and Malachi Toney, but slipped to third at +340 on FanDuel Sportsbook after the loss.

Smith still produced — 10 catches on 12 targets for 83 yards and a touchdown — but CBS notes much of it came late, with Ohio State trailing by three scores. A receiver who had been averaging just under 19 yards per catch managed only 8.3 yards per reception, a considerable decline by his standards.

Against a USC defense that had surrendered 11 passes of 30-plus yards this season, his longest catch went for just 27 yards.

The quarterback problem in Columbus

The pivot point is Luke Fahey, thrust into his debut start after Sayin's injury.

CBS Sports reports Fahey went 21-of-38 for 260 yards and one touchdown, with accuracy down the field a persistent problem — including a well-underthrown ball that cost what should have been a long Smith touchdown, on which Smith slipped while adjusting.

Most of Fahey's work stayed short and intermediate, and CBS speculates Ohio State may shift toward a run-heavy approach to keep him comfortable.

Rainy conditions in Los Angeles may have exacerbated the deep-ball issues, but the effect was the same: no explosives against one of the friendliest defenses left on the schedule.

Miami's stars are surging in the opposite direction

While Smith's opportunities shrink, CBS Sports reports Miami's game flow works in the opposite direction: a leaky Hurricanes defense forces the Mensah-to-Toney combo to let it rip all game.

Against North Carolina in a 38-35 shootout win, Mensah went 22-of-29 for 274 yards and three touchdowns to take over favorite status at +170, while Toney caught two scores — including the game-sealing touchdown in the final minutes — to sit at +290.

With Notre Dame up next, both Hurricanes stars get a national spotlight to build a late Heisman moment.

The stakes: an uphill fight for a rare receiver Heisman

If Smith is going to join the exclusive list of receivers to win the Heisman Trophy, CBS Sports argues it now requires winning what has become an uphill battle.

Ohio State's four remaining opponents — Oregon, Northwestern, Nebraska and Michigan — are each statistically better at preventing explosive pass plays than USC, meaning downfield chances may only get scarcer.

Per CBS, Smith needs rapid improvement from his young quarterback, some help from Notre Dame's defense against Miami's duo, and spectacular after-the-catch plays with fewer deep opportunities.

Yahoo Sports, meanwhile, frames the team-level stakes: a Buckeyes squad suddenly in danger of slipping from the playoff picture entirely.

What comes next

The calendar offers Smith little room to maneuver. ESPN reports Riley's Trojans (7-2, 4-2 Big Ten) revived their own playoff hopes with the win, meaning Ohio State's remaining opponents have every incentive to bring their best.

Smith's Heisman chances, as CBS Sports puts it, now feel as much in Notre Dame's hands as his own — if the Irish stymie Miami's stars, the door reopens.

Otherwise, Smith exits Columbus as the best receiver in Big Ten history by CBS's assessment, with a case as one of the best college football has seen in recent memory, but perhaps without the trophy. Riley, for his part, told reporters the win is 'important for now.

It's important for later.'

Sources

  1. espn.com › USC saves CFP hopes with upset of Ohio State as embattled Riley savors win
  2. sports.yahoo.com › Yahoo Top 10: Ohio State tumbles out of rankings, paving way for a new No. 1
  3. cbssports.com › Jeremiah Smith's Heisman hopes take hit after Ohio State's offense sputtered with new QB in USC loss

More on Books