Apple HomeView Reviews: $299 Smart Display Splits Critics

Apple's first smart display launches November 13 at $299, and critics praise its polish but say it's a tough sell outside Apple's ecosystem.

@sharedot

Apple HomeView Reviews: $299 Smart Display Splits Critics

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Gadgets
  • Apple
  • Smart Home
  • Homeview
  • Siri AI

Apple's first smart display launches November 13 at $299, and critics praise its polish but say it's a tough sell outside Apple's ecosystem.

What happened: Apple's first smart display arrives

Apple's first dedicated smart display goes on sale November 13 at $299, a month after its October 13 announcement.

HomeView packs a 7-inch Liquid Retina display (1088 x 1088 at 220 ppi) with True Tone and 500 nits of peak brightness, an A18 chip, a 12MP Center Stage camera, and an audio system with two full-range drivers, a down-firing woofer and passive radiators.

It comes as a tabletop unit in silver, starlight, rose pink or space gray, or as a wall-mounted version at the same price.

Man of Many's Ben McKimm, who lived with the device for a week, notes the display dims to just 0.3 nits — the lowest brightness Apple has ever shipped — making it usable as a bedside clock.

Why it's surprising: the spy-on-your-family problem

The Verge's Jennifer Pattison Tuohy scored the HomeView 7 out of 10 and found the oddest flaw isn't hardware — it's that HomeView is both a communal family device and an extension of your iPhone.

Personal texts and calendars appear on the kitchen screen when your paired phone is on the same Wi-Fi network, and she reports she could easily read her 15-year-old daughter's text messages, and vice versa. Her daughter's verdict: "I'll just use my iPhone."

Meanwhile her tech-averse husband loved it and asked for one for his office.

The two-step check — facial recognition plus a nearby iPhone or Apple Watch rather than Face ID — unlocks personal content for up to six people, but The Verge found clunky authentication checks and being bounced to the iPhone interrupt the hands-free experience.

The gaps reviewers found

The complaints are specific. XDA's Patrick O'Rourke reports there is no app store, and third-party apps adapted from CarPlay — the display runs on the same framework — seemingly appear at random with no way to remove or manage them from the device.

He also found major apps like Google's suite including YouTube, Netflix and Prime Video missing at launch, pushing users toward Safari workarounds.

Startup Fortune's Dave Barr adds that apps like Sonos are absent, and that HomeView won't launch in the European Union at all because Siri AI isn't available there — shutting one of the biggest smart speaker regions out entirely.

Man of Many notes the wall-mounted model loses the base woofer and sells its mounts and power adapters separately: $60 for the USB-C wall connector and $80 for the AC wired mount, per XDA.

The evidence: what the scores say

The verdicts converge on the same split. The Verge gave it a 7 out of 10, calling it a gorgeous, speedy smart home hub and excellent hands-free kitchen companion, but stumbling when it tries to be the family iPhone, with Siri AI still slow at times.

XDA also scored it 7 out of 10, praising the iMac G4-inspired design and audio on par with the HomePod mini while faulting the price and app situation.

Gear Patrol, cited by Startup Fortune, calls it a wonderful but pricey display for the Apple power user; Tom's Guide found it well made with strong audio but short as a smart home display. Man of Many's full review is a yes: a no-brainer smart home hub for households already deep in the ecosystem.

The stakes: paying $299 for polish and lock-in

At $299, HomeView costs well above what Amazon and Google typically charge for their small screens, per Startup Fortune, and Apple is entering a category Echo Show and Nest Hub have owned for close to a decade.

The reviews suggest buyers are paying for polish and ecosystem lock-in: reasonable if you own an iPhone and Apple Watch and use Apple Music and FaceTime, but a mixed household still gets more for less from an Echo Show or Nest Hub.

Man of Many's testing did surface genuine hardware wins — distance-adaptive UI that scales text as you approach, Secure Exclaves isolating camera and mic feeds on the A18, and Spatial Audio that beats the Nest Hub and HomePod mini 2.

What comes next: the first real test

Startup Fortune frames HomeView as the first real test of whether people will pay a premium for a counter-bound AI assistant, with the first sales figures set to say whether a late start still counts for anything.

The launch also positions Apple against Google and Samsung on a shared bet: an AI assistant that follows you around beats one locked in a single gadget.

Android Authority, cited by Startup Fortune, reports Samsung's Android XR glasses pre-orders open November 12 with mid-December deliveries — Apple putting its assistant on the kitchen counter while its rivals put theirs on your face.

Sources

  1. startupfortune.com › Apple's $299 HomeView lands with reviews calling it great for iPhone owners
  2. manofmany.com › Apple HomeView Review: Does Apple's First Smart Display Deserve a Spot in Your Home?
  3. theverge.com › Apple's HomeView is my new favorite smart display — but not my daughter's
  4. xda-developers.com › The HomeView feels like a giant Apple Watch for your smart home, but it comes with some surprising limitations

More on Gadgets