Kim Kardashian Feared 'All's Fair' Was Career Suicide

Kim Kardashian feared career suicide after 'All's Fair' scored 6% on Rotten Tomatoes, but hate-watching made it a No. 1 hit renewed for season two.

@sharedot

Kim Kardashian Feared 'All's Fair' Was Career Suicide

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • Television
  • All S Fair
  • Kim Kardashian
  • Hulu
  • Tv Criticism

Kim Kardashian feared career suicide after 'All's Fair' scored 6% on Rotten Tomatoes, but hate-watching made it a No. 1 hit renewed for season two.

Kardashian Thought the Role Might End Her Career

Kim Kardashian, who plays divorce lawyer Allura Grant in Ryan Murphy's Hulu and Disney+ legal drama 'All's Fair,' tells AOL's Morning Honey that when the first season landed a disastrous 6% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, she believed it was career suicide.

According to the outlet, the 46-year-old said, 'There was a second when I thought, "Oh my God, my career is over," and these girls are gonna hate me because I just brought in this whole wave of hate that they've probably never experienced before in their amazing acting lives.'

The concern was about her co-stars Glenn Close, Sarah Paulson, Naomi Watts and Niecy Nash-Betts, whose careers she feared she had dragged into a critical pile-on.

The Hate-Watching Reversal That Made It Number One

Here is the twist that makes this story worth revisiting: the panning actually powered the show. Kardashian says the backlash converted into curiosity viewing.

'I just thought it was so funny that people came in and wanted to hate on it so much that the hate turned into viewers wanting to see how bad it was,' she told Morning Honey.

Per the outlet, she added that audiences 'tuned in and they made it like a number one show for weeks on end,' and she sees something 'funny and special and important' in proving that critics don't decide a show's fate.

The series was renewed for a second season, and 93.1 WZAK reports she has continued defending that success as criticism mounted again.

Season Two: 'Worst Show of the Century'?

The second season premiered November 4 on Hulu and Disney+, and critics, per 93.1 WZAK, are not changing their minds.

The Telegraph's Ed Power, in a one-star review, called 'All's Fair' a possible contender for the worst television series of the 21st century and sympathized with Naomi Watts and Glenn Close, even comparing Watts' wasted talents to her work in 'Mulholland Drive.'

The Guardian also gave the season one star, though critic Lucy Mangan admitted it is becoming more entertaining, edging toward so-bad-it's-good television.

93.1 WZAK notes Ready Steady Cut's Jonathon Wilson gave two stars and said the series seems caught between serious legal drama and self-aware campy comedy.

Paulson's Voicemail and What Comes Next

What changed Kardashian's mind about pressing on was a pep talk from within the cast. She tells Morning Honey that Sarah Paulson 'left me the nicest voicemail that gave me the most confidence and changed everything for me,' prompting her to double down.

Paulson, per the outlet, called Kardashian a 'special person' and praised her second-season work, saying there were scenes toward the end of the season where she and Naomi Watts reacted 'Jesus, woman,' and that Kardashian's personality was coming through her character in a way she found 'divine.'

With the new episodes streaming since November 4, the open question, as 93.1 WZAK frames it, is whether season two can convert its bad reviews into another ratings win.

Sources

  1. aol.com › Kim Kardashian admits she thought her career was over after harsh reviews of 'All's Fair' but credits critics for the show's surprising success - AOL
  2. wzakcleveland.com › Critics Slam Kim Kardashian Series Return, Call It 'Worst Show of the Century'

More on Television