DGA Bars Holmes Doc From Feature Prize, Doc Category Only
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Entertainment
- Film
- Awards
- Documentary
The DGA barred Nathan Fielder's A24 Holmes doc 'You Can See Everything' from its top feature award, restricting it to the documentary category.
The DGA Ruling That Reshapes the Race
A DGA representative confirmed to Variety that Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim's 'You Can See Everything' will not be considered for outstanding directorial achievement in theatrical feature film this season.
The guild's rule book states that "re-releases, animated films and documentaries are not eligible" for that prize, and Variety reports the line "seems to leave no room for a hybrid or an exception."
Instead, the A24 film about Elizabeth Holmes will compete solely in the outstanding directorial achievement in documentary category.
The film, which opened Oct. 16, blurs nonfiction and staged narrative, and A24 and its awards strategists had hoped its unusual construction might let the guild treat it as both a feature and a documentary.
A24's Failed Bid for Dual Classification
According to Variety, the argument inside the studio and among consultants gained momentum after Amanda Seyfried — who appears in the film and previously won an Emmy for playing Holmes in Hulu's 'The Dropout' — was positioned for supporting actress consideration at the Oscars.
The thinking was that a film straddling documentary and staged narrative might be treated as both a feature and a documentary by different bodies.
The DGA sees it differently: the guild classifies films based on how they are produced and submitted, and by that measure this is a documentary, regardless of how other awards bodies or voting blocs interpret it. A24 declined to comment to Variety.
Why Losing the DGA Feature Prize Hurts
Variety notes the DGA feature award is one of the most reliable Oscars bellwethers: only eight times in the guild's history has its winner failed to go on to win the best director Oscar. Without a shot at that prize, the film loses a key piece of precursor momentum.
AOL's Matt Singer adds that the guild's rules explicitly exclude documentaries from the theatrical feature category, so the film cannot win the forerunner award — though a documentary win at the guild could still bolster its standing with the Academy.
Variety reports A24 remains in active conversations with BAFTA, SAG-AFTRA and the Golden Globes about how the film should be classified.
Can a Documentary Still Reach Best Picture?
AOL's analysis addresses the open question: no documentary has ever received a Best Picture nomination in the Academy's 90-plus-year history, but it is not technically impossible.
AOL lays out the eligibility rules — a qualifying seven-day run in one of six major markets with at least three daily screenings, an expanded theatrical run in nine additional top-50 markets within 45 days, and meeting two of four Representation and Inclusion Standards.
Variety reports the film is being submitted across categories including best picture, director, supporting actress for Seyfried and supporting actor for Christopher Abbott, alongside documentary feature. DGA nominations will be announced in January.
A Box Office and Critical Juggernaut
The ruling lands while the 174-minute film is still surging: Yahoo reports it earned $19.5 million domestically in its second weekend for a $45.1 million total, making it one of the highest-grossing documentaries ever, with a 97 Metacritic score and 98% on Rotten Tomatoes as of Oct. 27.
Yahoo's critic Brett Arnold called it "a brilliant film that feels like it could, and should, become the first documentary ever nominated for Best Picture."
Neither Holmes nor Evans has seen the film, per Fielder and Oppenheim at the Los Angeles premiere, and Yahoo reports A24 has not announced streaming plans, though its HBO Max deal and typical 30–45 day window suggest mid-November to early December.