McDonald's Franchisees Revolt Over $800K Remodel Bills

Franchise operators are pushing back on McDonald's 'Next' plan, which asks them to fund $800,000 remodels of 46,000-plus restaurants.

@sharedot

McDonald's Franchisees Revolt Over $800K Remodel Bills

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • Food
  • Fast Food
  • Mcdonald S
  • Franchisees

Franchise operators are pushing back on McDonald's 'Next' plan, which asks them to fund $800,000 remodels of 46,000-plus restaurants.

The $1.2 Million Tab Per Store

McDonald's is asking its U.S. franchisees to fund roughly $800,000 in upgrades per location under a multiyear turnaround called 'Next,' unveiled by CEO Chris Kempczinski in June to improve food quality, service and efficiency across more than 46,000 restaurants, according to Bloomberg reporting carried by The Independent and the Financial Post.

The Financial Post adds that operators are already on the hook for scheduled remodels costing at least $400,000, bringing the total potential tab to about $1.2 million per restaurant.

McDonald's has pledged about $8.5 billion in cash and rent relief to offset part of the cost, with support varying by franchisee.

Why Operators Are Balking

The pushback is notable because the stakes for the company are unusually high: the Financial Post reports McDonald's shares plunged 32 percent from a late-February peak through the end of September, erasing nearly $80 billion in market value and putting the stock on course for its worst year since 2002.

Franchise owners, meeting through an elected operators' association, say they were surprised by the price tag and are questioning the plan's lack of detail and its cost, according to Bloomberg via The Independent.

Operators worry about taking on debt and want specifics on what sales lift to expect; they even persuaded the company to postpone prototype tours until next year to focus on immediate traffic concerns.

The Company's Defense and Analysts' Math

McDonald's CFO Ian Borden told investors the investments 'will be phased over time,' so franchisees can invest progressively as capabilities are deployed, The Independent reports, and the company has set funds aside to help some restaurants.

Kempczinski told Bloomberg, per the Financial Post, that the company is putting up $8.5 billion to help operators reach the at-least-20-percent returns they historically expected, saying 'We're willing to partner with the franchisees as a demonstration of our faith.'

Guggenheim Securities analyst Gregory Francfort, cited by both outlets, suspects franchisees will negotiate the price tag down 20 to 40 percent as they accept some elements and reject others.

The company says the program should save operators about $100,000 in annual cash flow through initiatives like automated order-taking.

Stakes: Value Wars, Lawsuits and History

The revolt comes as McDonald's, like other fast-food chains, struggles to lure choosier diners.

The Financial Post reports U.S. sales slowed in part because the value lineup underperformed last quarter, while beef, labour and equipment costs keep climbing — pressure underscored by a Wendy's franchisee bankruptcy.

The Independent notes a customer lawsuit filed in October alleging AI-driven pricing across franchises, which McDonald's denies, saying AI pricing is only a suggestion and each store sets its own prices.

There is history here, too: after a 2017 revamp pushed remodels and kiosks, more than 85 percent of franchisees signed on but later resisted the cost, prompting an independent advocacy group in 2018 that won operators more time.

Franchisees are now weighing their next steps through the National Franchisee Leadership Alliance.

Sources

  1. the-independent.com › McDonald's franchisees are fighting back after the burger giant pushes big change
  2. financialpost.com › McDonald's franchisees balk at costly bill to upgrade stores

More on Food