Colts' OT Coin-Toss Gamble Backfires as Chiefs Win 33-30
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Horoscope
- NFL
- Kansas City Chiefs
- Indianapolis Colts
- Overtime
Indianapolis chose to kick off in overtime at Arrowhead, but Patrick Mahomes and Harrison Butker made the Chiefs' second chance count in a 33-30 win.
What Happened: A Coin Toss, A Gamble, A Loss
After winning the overtime coin toss, Colts head coach Shane Steichen elected to kick off rather than receive, telling reporters he did not want to hand Mahomes' offense the freedom of four downs if Indianapolis settled for a field goal first.
"We wanted to play defense there, and then we had four downs we were going to get offensively," Steichen said, per the Indianapolis Star via Yahoo Sports.
The defense nearly delivered a three-and-out, but Tyquan Thornton's 30-yard catch on third-and-12 kept Kansas City alive, and Harrison Butker's field goal put the Chiefs ahead 30-27.
The Overturned Fumble That Flipped the Finish
The strangest sequence came on Indianapolis' first offensive possession of overtime. Daniel Jones hit Laquon Treadwell for 48 yards, the ball came loose, and Kansas City recovered what was initially ruled a game-ending fumble.
Officials instead determined that cornerback L'Jarius Sneed contacted Treadwell's hip before the ball came out, making him down by contact. Andy Reid told KMBC he saw all the replays and "would have voted against it going the other way, but I don't have a vote."
Mahomes joked he was glad to "prove it the right way."
Mahomes Delivers a Vintage Night
Mahomes finished with 382 passing yards and three touchdowns, his first game with at least 350 yards and three scores since Week 1 of the 2022 season, according to KC Kingdom. Travis Kelce caught nine passes for 101 yards and a touchdown, while Kenneth Walker III rumbled for 117 rushing yards.
Arrowhead Addict calls the performance legitimate MVP form in just his second game back from ACL surgery. Steichen's own summary was blunt: "we fought like crazy, but it wasn't good enough."
The Fourth-and-8 Decision That Decided It
Facing fourth-and-8 inside the Kansas City red zone with a chance to win, the Colts nearly rolled the dice, but did not get the look they wanted and Spencer Shrader kicked a field goal to tie it at 30. That handed Mahomes a second opportunity.
The New York Post reports he changed the play into a 22-yard pass to Walker after Rashee Rice's perimeter block, setting up Butker's 40-yard kick as time expired — the second straight year Kansas City has beaten Indianapolis on an overtime field goal.
Why the Gamble Matters
The Indianapolis Star notes that since the current overtime rule was adopted, teams receiving the opening kick were 10-6-1 entering Sunday, though kicking off allows a team to win with a field goal after a stop — exactly what Green Bay did against the Jets earlier that day.
Free safety Camryn Bynum said the defense saw Steichen's call as a chance for redemption: "No matter what, we knew the game was in our hands." The Colts fall to 0-2 after Kansas City held the ball for all but 2:22 of the third quarter.
What Comes Next
The Chiefs move to 2-0 despite a defense that, per KC Kingdom, recorded no sacks and surrendered more than 130 all-purpose yards and two touchdowns to Jonathan Taylor after holding Denver to 10 points a week earlier.
Arrowhead Addict flags the short recovery, noting Kansas City played Monday night in Week 1 and then logged over three real-time hours Sunday.
The Colts' defensive communication tweaks — Akeem Davis-Gaither relaying plays instead of Camryn Bynum — did not seem to help, and both teams now face quick turnarounds.
Sources
- sports.yahoo.com › Colts bet on their defense in overtime. Patrick Mahomes made them pay
- kmbc.com › Andy Reid, Patrick Mahomes react to overturned fumble in Chiefs-Colts overtime thriller
- nypost.com › Patrick Mahomes, Chiefs beat Colts in overtime thriller
- kckingdom.com › What we learned from Chiefs Week 2 overtime thriller over Colts
- arrowheadaddict.com › 7 instant takeaways from Chiefs' wild overtime win over Colts