Supreme Court Blocks Trump Mail Ballot Rule for Midterms

The Supreme Court refused Monday to let the Postal Service enforce new mail ballot restrictions ahead of November's midterms, with Alito and Thomas dissenting.

@sharedot

Supreme Court Blocks Trump Mail Ballot Rule for Midterms

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • US News
  • Supreme Court
  • Mail In Voting
  • 2026 Midterms
  • Elections

The Supreme Court refused Monday to let the Postal Service enforce new mail ballot restrictions ahead of November's midterms, with Alito and Thomas dissenting.

What Happened

In a brief, unsigned order, the court said the administration 'is unlikely to succeed on the merits of its challenge' to a lower court's preliminary injunction, and that the equitable factors did not favor a stay.

The decision caps a flurry of last-minute legal action with voting already underway in several states.

Why the Ruling Surprised Observers

The outcome was striking because the same court had given the administration a procedural win on August 24, lifting an earlier injunction against Trump's March executive order, and because the conservative majority has repeatedly sided with the administration on its emergency docket.

This time, even a Trump-appointed judge, District Judge Carl Nichols, had ruled against the rule on Sunday, writing that no statute grants the Postal Service the power to issue key parts of it.

Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas dissented, with Alito writing that the Postal Service 'has broad authority to regulate the mail' and that practical implementation concerns were 'not enough' to deny the application.

The Evidence Against Implementing the Rule

Election officials in both parties told the courts there was no time to carry out a complete overhaul weeks before the election. Alabama, North Carolina and Wisconsin had already begun sending mail ballots while the new system was inactive.

A whistleblower report warned the Postal Service's barcode and portal systems were flawed, and that a single barcode error could cause an entire batch of ballots to be rejected.

States told the high court that compliance would be impossible in some states, meaning millions of voters would be unable to vote by mail. The First Circuit had also found the rule would likely disenfranchise millions while providing minimal gains in combating fraud.

What the Rule Would Have Required

Under the rule, issued at the direction of the White House after Trump's March executive order, states would have had to submit lists of mail ballot recipients to the Postal Service and use agency-approved envelope designs with unique barcodes.

The agency could have refused to deliver non-compliant ballots.

The administration described the measure as 'modest envelope-designed and addressee-information requirements,' but the 23 states and the District of Columbia that challenged it, along with voting rights groups including the League of Women Voters, called it an unconstitutional federal power grab over state-run elections.

The Political Stakes

The midterms will determine control of Congress, and mail voting carries political weight because Democratic voters disproportionately use it.

Nearly a third of the electorate, about 47 million people, voted by mail in 2024, according to Democracy Docket, and USA Today notes nearly 30% of voters cast ballots that way in 2024, with Democrats more likely to do so per the MIT Election Data & Science Lab.

All 50 states allow some form of mail voting, and eight conduct elections entirely by mail, making the rule potentially especially disruptive in states like Washington and Oregon, whose officials welcomed the ruling.

What Comes Next

The court's action blocks the rule only for this election cycle.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh, in a brief concurrence, wrote that while there is 'a fair prospect' the Postal Service has authority to issue the rule, officials lacked sufficient time to implement it before the midterms — signaling the issue could return for future elections.

Meanwhile, litigation continues: Judge Talwani's order lets states voluntarily comply with parts of the rule, and Mother Jones reports a separate portion of Trump's executive order directing DHS to build a nationwide citizenship database remains on hold and will be considered separately by the Supreme Court.

Sources

  1. democracydocket.com › Supreme Court rejects Trump bid to revive mail voting restrictions ahead of midterms
  2. pbs.org › Supreme Court rejects Trump mail ballot restrictions ahead of midterms
  3. nbcnews.com › Supreme Court says Trump can't enforce new mail-in ballot regulation
  4. news8000.com › In loss for Trump, US Supreme Court won't let Postal Service restrict mail ballots
  5. cnn.com › Supreme Court rejects Trump's plan to limit mail-in voting in midterms
  6. guampdn.com › U.S. Supreme Court rejects mail-in voting order
  7. usatoday.com › Supreme Court won't clear way for Trump's mailed ballot rules
  8. motherjones.com › Supreme Court blocks Trump's mail ballot scheme

More on US News