Sanders Bill Would Ban Superintelligence, Create Dept. of AI

Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Greg Casar introduced legislation Wednesday to permanently ban artificial superintelligence and pause advanced AI development.

@sharedot

Sanders Bill Would Ban Superintelligence, Create Dept. of AI

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • AI
  • AI Policy
  • Bernard Sanders
  • Superintelligence

Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Greg Casar introduced legislation Wednesday to permanently ban artificial superintelligence and pause advanced AI development.

What the Ban Artificial Superintelligence Act Would Do

Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Greg Casar unveiled legislation Wednesday that would permanently prohibit artificial superintelligence, defined as a system that exceeds human cognitive ability or could plan and execute the destruction or disempowerment of humanity.

The bill would pause development of the most advanced AI systems until new federal safety rules are written by a newly created Department of Artificial Intelligence, after which advanced systems would need federal approval before deployment.

Violations could carry penalties of up to 20 years in prison in some cases.

Casar told reporters the ban would partly work by prohibiting companies from using recursive self-improvement, meaning AI models building more advanced versions of themselves, calling it a return to a time when humans were in charge of AI research.

Why the Bill Is a Political Lightning Rod

The proposal stands out for its extremity relative to anything Congress has considered so far: lawmakers have struggled to coalesce around even less sweeping AI regulations, and this bill would permanently outlaw a category of technology before it exists.

"It doesn't take a genius to say, 'slow it down,'" Sanders said in an interview with AP, asking whether Americans really want a superintelligence that could act independently of human control.

HuffPost reports the bill is titled the Ban Artificial Superintelligence Act and that Sanders warned, "We cannot simply sit by idly and wait for advanced AI to cause the next 9/11 or Chernobyl or a global pandemic or a financial crisis."

AI Company Employees Endorse the Measure

Despite coming from progressive lawmakers often at odds with Silicon Valley, the bill drew a statement of support from a number of current employees at leading AI companies, according to a statement shared with AP.

Juan Felipe Cerón Uribe, a researcher in OpenAI's Safety Systems, said "superintelligence could either go extremely right or extremely wrong" and that "we shouldn't be playing such games."

Swante Scholz, a software engineer at Google DeepMind who said he was not speaking for his employer, said the most likely outcome on the current path is "an existential catastrophe for humanity," calling a ban on superintelligence development a positive change for the foreseeable future.

Neither OpenAI nor Google DeepMind has endorsed the bill as companies.

Trump's Opposition and the China Argument

President Donald Trump has resisted calls for greater AI oversight, putting him at odds with tech leaders including Anthropic's Dario Amodei, OpenAI's Sam Altman and xAI's Elon Musk.

On Tuesday, Trump told the United Nations General Assembly that artificial intelligence will be renamed "super intelligence," and Fox Business reports he reiterated opposition to new regulation while saying the Justice Department could step in if necessary.

The central argument against sweeping restrictions is that the U.S. would slow development while China continues advancing — a concern Rep. James Comer raised about falling behind in the AI race.

Sanders countered that avoiding the most dangerous forms of AI will ultimately require U.S.-China cooperation, comparing it to nuclear arms control: "Ronald Reagan... was smart enough to understand that he had to sit down with Gorbachev."

Long Odds, But a Marker for 2028

The bill faces long odds in the Republican-controlled Congress, which has been unable to pass even modest AI safeguards.

But it signals how the progressive wing of the Democratic Party is approaching AI ahead of November's midterms and a 2028 campaign in which the technology is expected to be a prominent issue.

Potential 2028 candidates are moving too: Maryland Gov. Wes Moore announced an AI regulation plan Tuesday, and California Gov. Gavin Newsom signed an executive order to accelerate independent oversight of AI companies.

Sanders has made AI a signature issue, introducing a sovereign wealth fund financed by a one-time tax on the largest AI companies in June and appearing alongside Republicans including Steve Bannon at an AI conference last week.

HuffPost notes Sanders also warned of losing some 6 million transportation jobs to driverless vehicles.

What Happens Next

HuffPost reports Congress is unlikely to act before November's midterm elections, and lawmakers appear far from consensus even on narrower proposals.

AI safety is expected to be central to talks between Trump and China's Xi Jinping at the White House this week, and Sanders has urged Trump to negotiate a pause on advanced AI development and an international ban on superintelligence.

Sanders' bill would make it U.S. policy to pursue international agreements and coordination with allies aimed at preventing superintelligence development worldwide, per Fox Business.

Public pressure is building from another direction too: an AP-NORC poll found 53% of Americans are extremely or very concerned about AI's environmental impacts, up from 41% last year. Whether the bill advances or not, it has drawn a line for how far AI regulation debates can go.

Sources

  1. abcnews.com › Sen. Sanders unveils bill to ban artificial superintelligence, create Dept. of AI
  2. sg.news.yahoo.com › Bernie Sanders Introduces Promised Bill To Pause AI Development
  3. orovillemr.com › Sen. Bernie Sanders unveils bill to ban artificial superintelligence and create Department of AI
  4. foxbusiness.com › Employees at AI companies back Bernie Sanders bill cracking down on development

More on AI