Judge Blocks Border Wall Construction in Big Bend

A federal judge blocked Trump's border wall expansion in Texas's Big Bend, ruling plaintiffs likely to win their challenge.

@sharedot

Judge Blocks Border Wall Construction in Big Bend

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • US News
  • Immigration
  • Border Wall
  • Texas
  • Courts

A federal judge blocked Trump's border wall expansion in Texas's Big Bend, ruling plaintiffs likely to win their challenge.

What happened

US District Judge Kathleen Cardone issued a temporary injunction Friday after a hearing in El Paso, blocking Customs and Border Protection from border security construction or ground disturbance across the Big Bend region of west Texas unless it complies with the federal laws the Department of Homeland Security tried to suspend.

Cardone found the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on at least one claim, would suffer serious irreparable harm without an injunction, and that the equities and public interest favored them.

Why it's a blow to the administration

The ruling stalls a key Trump campaign promise at one of its most contested flashpoints, just weeks after the first wall panels went up in the Big Bend sector in mid-September.

CBP had already awarded five contracts totaling more than $6 billion for the region as part of a roughly $46.5 billion border expansion funded through last year's spending bill.

A CBP spokesperson said the agency stands by its assessment, remains confident in its legal authorities, and is working with the Department of Justice on next steps.

The legal challenge

The lawsuit was filed by the Center for Biological Diversity, the Friends of the Ruidosa church, and river guide Billy Miller, arguing DHS was wrong to issue waivers suspending dozens of environmental and historical protection laws to speed construction.

Laiken Jordahl of the Center for Biological Diversity called it a historic victory and a total victory, saying the bulldozers would be sent packing until the judge rules on the merits, while warning the fight is far from over.

Why Big Bend became a battleground

Images of bulldozers clearing ground in the park in August sparked outrage from Republicans and Democrats alike, prompting CBP commissioner Rodney Scott to briefly pause construction, but work resumed in September.

Opponents argue the 500-mile region is so remote and rugged, with prominent cliffs and no nearby cities on the Mexican side, that it deters crossings on its own.

Resistance along the river

The injunction also echoes grassroots resistance elsewhere in Texas.

In San Ygnacio, a town of roughly 400 residents, locals including 90-year-old fisherman Joel Ruiz and environmental investigator Elsa Hull blocked crews, were arrested, and unearthed 75-year-old land records showing the federal government never acquired excluded riverfront land.

Attorney Ricardo de Anda filed two lawsuits alleging Fifth Amendment takings, and the Guardian reports crews agreed to stop construction on the disputed land for now, a verbal concession rather than a court order.

What comes next

The injunction is temporary; Cardone has yet to rule on the merits of the case, and the administration says it is reevaluating plans for the national park without saying what it will do there.

Advocates, including National Parks Conservation Association president Tiernan Sittenfeld, want the government to repair damage already done and develop alternatives with border communities.

CBP has also said in court filings that it was prepared to refer some landowner disputes to the Justice Department, so legal fights over private property remain unresolved.

Sources

  1. theguardian.com › Federal judge halts Big Bend border wall construction in blow to Trump agenda
  2. dailynews.com › Judge temporarily blocks border wall construction in Texas' Big Bend region
  3. indiatoday.in › Texas court halts Trump border wall work in Big Bend
  4. aol.co.uk › A small Texas town stopped Trump's border wall construction – for now

More on US News