Big Walk's 10 Lines of AI Code Split the IGF Jury
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Culture
- Indie Games
- AI
- Igf Awards
House House disclosed that LLMs helped fix one Unity bug in Big Walk, and 19 IGF jurors now refuse to vote for any game using generative AI.
What Happened: A Belated Disclosure
House House, the studio behind the co-op exploration game Big Walk, publicly admitted this week that LLMs were used "sparingly" in the final stretch of development, according to Aftermath, which first received the studio's statement.
Ars Technica reports the controversy broke into public view Monday when 19 members of the 50-plus-member Independent Games Festival jury released a signed statement "declining to vote for any game that uses generative AI in any capacity," citing ecological, economic, psychological and labor harms.
Though the jurors named no games, attention quickly turned to Big Walk, and House House added its disclosure to the game's FAQ page, saying it was now "a matter of public interest."
The Bug That Needed a Chatbot
The specifics, as Aftermath lays out in House House's full statement, are strikingly small: a Unity engine bug rendered shadow casters at an "infinite distance" behind the player, slowing the game 50% for roughly 20 seconds at sunrise and sunset.
After consulting a Unity engineer who concluded the fix "wasn't possible," the studio posed the problem to an LLM chatbot.
It suggested a fix the developers had to "modify extensively" into about 10 lines of code — which House House estimates represents well under 0.1% of the game's code, with no other generative AI use anywhere in production.
Ars Technica notes at least one social media user claims the bug was fixable with significant human effort.
The Jury's Pain and the Divided Response
The reaction reveals how personal this fight has become. Ars Technica reports juror Austin Walker called Big Walk "remarkable" and "beautiful," and fellow juror Damon Reece said the game felt like "home" — yet both still declined to vote for it.
"We have our hands on the lever here," Reece wrote, calling the pain of punishing a beloved game necessary to "prioritize human creativity and labour." The game's Steam page has been hit with over 400 negative reviews, per Ars Technica, though its "Very Positive" rating holds.
The outlet also notes precedent: the Indie Game Awards rescinded honors for Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 last year over AI-generated textures later patched out.
Is Zero Tolerance the Right Line?
The disagreement is now about policy, not just one game.
Ars Technica quotes juror Liz Ryerson saying she didn't find House House's use disqualifying and that acting like "there aren't any levels to this" bothers her, while curator Dominic Tarason calls Big Walk "very mildly compromised art" that is "absolutely, unquestionably art and very human."
House House itself apologized that its LLM usage "may not meet their standards" and admitted, per Aftermath, that the lack of an internal AI policy "was a failure" it will fix.
Meanwhile, the studio told Steam doesn't even request disclosure of chatbot usage — a gap the IGF jurors want closed with a full anti-AI policy.