Drake's 'Janice STFU' Chorus Lawsuit Dropped in 10 Days
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Music
- Drake
- Copyright
- Janice Stfu
Aviel Hirschfield voluntarily withdrew his copyright suit against Drake over 'Janice STFU' just 10 days after filing, without explaining why.
The Lawsuit Ends Before It Begins
Oregon producer and songwriter Aviel Hirschfield — known professionally as GoodbyeCalev — has withdrawn his federal copyright lawsuit against Drake, OVO Sound, UMG Recordings and Universal Music Publishing over the chart-topping 'Iceman' hit 'Janice STFU.'
Court documents filed Tuesday, October 27, show the case was dismissed 'in its entirety without prejudice,' roughly 10 days after it was filed on October 16 in California federal court. Rolling Stone first reported the withdrawal, and Complex independently confirmed it through the court filings.
Neither Hirschfield nor his lawyer has publicly explained the about-face; when Complex reached the attorney for comment Tuesday, the lawyer declined to speak.
Because the dismissal was entered without prejudice, Hirschfield technically retains the option to modify and refile the claims in the future, though no court has ruled on whether Drake copied any portion of his work.
Why the Rapid Retreat Surprised Readers
The speed of the reversal is what makes this story remarkable. As Rolling Stone reports, the suit was 'covered and dissected endlessly' in the week-plus after it was filed, from music publications to the Canadian press to podcasts and viral threads — and then it collapsed barely 10 days later.
Hirschfield's own representatives had been emphatic just days earlier, telling Rolling Stone that 'the complaint speaks for itself' and insisting the song was written specifically for Drake using music from his producers.
TheSource frames the collapse bluntly, noting 'a fight that deflates this fast still tells its own story and might just validate the doubters who saw right through this one.'
Drake's team, meanwhile, had called the suit a 'manufactured and baseless attempt' to exploit the artist's name for money and attention, with a rep stating flatly: 'Drake wrote this song and has no connection or knowledge of this person, full stop.'
The Demo at the Center of the Storm
The case turned on a recording leaked to X on October 19, presented as Hirschfield's demo with a pitched-down vocal performing a chorus closely resembling Drake's released hook.
A legal representative for Hirschfield confirmed to Pitchfork, as Exclaim! reports, that the circulating audio matched the material submitted as evidence, and his reps told Rolling Stone that 'multiple experts' had examined the file's metadata and deemed it legitimate.
But skepticism mounted almost immediately online.
TheSource recounts that YouTube creator What's the Dirt isolated the demo's vocals, lined them up against Drake's official release, and argued the waveforms matched identically — suggesting the alleged demo was actually Drake's finished hook, pitch-shifted and filtered over a leaked FnZ instrumental.
Drake's lawyers publicly accused Hirschfield of manipulating metadata and timestamps, and even sent him a cease-and-desist demanding he stop claiming authorship, according to Digital Music News.
Timeline Problems Doomed the Claim
Beyond the demo itself, the suit's chronology faced hard contradictions. Hirschfield claimed he composed the chorus between December 2025 and January 2026, completing his recording around January 25 over a beat supplied by production duo FnZ.
Yet, as Rolling Stone notes, one of the song's producers told Billboard the beat wasn't written until March — months after Hirschfield says he laid down vocals to it.
TheSource also points out that Drake previewed an early version of the track, then titled 'That's Just How I Feel,' during an Iceman livestream in September 2025, before the demo was allegedly recorded.
And the melody itself cut against the claim: 'Janice STFU' interpolates Lykke Li's 2011 classic 'I Follow Rivers,' and, per The Source, Drake's camp had already cleared the publishing with Lykke Li's team from the start — meaning Hirschfield was, in that outlet's framing, claiming a melody Drake had paid another artist to use.
What Was at Stake for Both Sides
The financial stakes were enormous, because 'Janice STFU' is one of the biggest hits of Drake's career.
As Complex notes, the song spent two weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 and has now logged 23 total weeks on the chart, sitting at No. 24, while Digital Music News reports it spent over 20 weeks atop the Hot Rap Songs chart — Drake's longest-leading rap chart hit ever.
Hirschfield's now-withdrawn complaint sought damages and profits tied to that success, along with a jury trial, without stating a dollar figure, per AllHipHop.
The case also leaned heavily on Hirschfield's most famous credential: a co-writing credit on Beyoncé's 'Heated' from 'Renaissance,' a song Drake is also credited on — a connection his suit emphasized heavily.
AllHipHop adds that Drake had already sampled Lykke Li's 'Little Bit' on his 2009 mixtape 'So Far Gone,' underscoring how public the song's musical roots were.
What Comes Next for Drake and His Accuser
For now, the door is only cracked shut: the without-prejudice dismissal means Hirschfield could amend and refile, but Baller Alert notes there has been no public explanation for the withdrawal and no ruling on the underlying claims.
Complex reports Hirschfield's lawyer declined comment, and HotNewHipHop observes the outcome is both a legal and optics win for Drake, arriving as skeptics' doubts about the metadata-heavy claim hardened online.
The timing adds a surreal footnote: the dismissal landed as Drake celebrated his 40th birthday at New York's Casa Cipriani over the weekend, where Digital Music News reports he gave away million-dollar prizes and surprised guests by joining the Backstreet Boys onstage for 'I Want It That Way.'
Producer Boi-1da, as quoted by The Source, summed up the industry's weary view: 'Every time you make a hit song there's always some weirdo plotting to say you stole it from them. It's happened to me every single time.'
Sources
- rollingstone.com › Drake 'Janice STFU' Copyright Lawsuit is Withdrawn
- complex.com › Drake Copyright Lawsuit Over "Janice STFU" Dismissed Without Prejudice
- allhiphop.com › Drake's "Janice STFU" Accuser Withdraws Copyright Lawsuit
- kisscleveland.iheart.com › Drake's 'Janice STFU' Copyright Lawsuit Voluntarily Dismissed
- thesource.com › DISMISSED: 'Janice STFU' Lawsuit in Shambles After Plaintiff Withdraws Claim in Just 10 Days
- exclaim.ca › Drake's "Janice STFU" Copyright Lawsuit Has Been Withdrawn
- digitalmusicnews.com › Drake 'Janice STFU' Copyright Lawsuit Dropped After A Few Days
- balleralert.com › "Janice STFU" Lawsuit Dropped as Drake Case Ends in 11 Days
- hotnewhiphop.com › Aviel Hirschfield Withdraws Drake "Janice STFU" Copyright Lawsuit