Kroger and Albertsons Clash in $9.3 Billion Merger Trial

Albertsons seeks $9.3 billion from Kroger in a Delaware trial over their failed $24.6 billion merger.

@sharedot

Kroger and Albertsons Clash in $9.3 Billion Merger Trial

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Business
  • Mergers And Acquisitions
  • Kroger
  • Albertsons
  • Antitrust

Albertsons seeks $9.3 billion from Kroger in a Delaware trial over their failed $24.6 billion merger.

The Trial Begins in Delaware

Former Albertsons CEO Vivek Sankaran was expected to be the first witness as a two-week bench trial kicked off Monday in the Delaware Court of Chancery over responsibility for the failed $24.6 billion Kroger-Albertsons merger — the largest in U.S. supermarket history.

Former Kroger CEO Rodney McMullen, Albertsons M&A chief Tom Moriarty, and outside antitrust attorneys Ted Hassi (for Albertsons) and Michael Bernstein (for Kroger) were also slated to testify. Vice Chancellor Lori Will will decide the case alone, without a jury.

What Albertsons Claims

Albertsons argues Kroger was unwilling to sell an adequate package of stores to win antitrust approval and instead focused on internal profit targets.

Its divestiture plan to C&S Wholesale Grocers grew from 238 stores to 579, but Albertsons says the stores chosen were the weakest performers, picked so Kroger could keep the most profitable ones.

Albertsons also alleges Kroger ignored FTC divestiture advice and failed to adequately engage with state attorneys general.

Kroger's Defense

Kroger says it invested more than $1 billion pursuing and defending the deal but faced regulators determined to block it, arguing no additional steps would have changed the outcome under then-FTC Chairwoman Lina Khan.

Kroger contends it relied on its antitrust counsel's advice, and that the FTC's narrow view of the grocery landscape would have required divesting more than the 650-store cap set in the merger agreement. Kroger also claims Albertsons breached the agreement through secret communications with C&S.

The Stakes at $9.3 Billion

Albertsons seeks the $600 million termination fee plus interest and costs, and more than $8 billion for lost shareholder value, totaling over $9.3 billion. To collect beyond the breakup fee, it must prove Kroger willfully breached the merger agreement.

Bloomberg Intelligence predicts Kroger will avoid damages but puts a 70% chance on paying the $600 million fee for a non-willful breach. Legal experts say the ruling could reshape how companies draft merger agreements over 'commercially reasonable efforts' in deals requiring divestitures.

What Comes Next

Judge Lori Will's ruling could take months, and either side could appeal to the Delaware Supreme Court.

Since the deal collapsed, both chains have moved to cut costs: Kroger plans to trim 3,000 corporate staff over three years, while Albertsons is conducting a comprehensive business review that could include asset sales.

The outcome will be watched closely for its implications for future large deals facing antitrust scrutiny.

Sources

  1. supermarketnews.com › Kroger, Albertsons ex-CEOs to testify in failed merger trial
  2. tradingview.com › The high-stakes case over the failed Albertsons-Kroger merger begins today
  3. ttnews.com › Kroger-Albertsons trial begins over failed merger

More on Business