Whistleblower: DHS Voter Probe May Break State Laws
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- US News
- Elections
- Homeland Security
- Whistleblower
- Voting
An anonymous federal whistleblower alleges DHS's 'Unlawful Voter Initiative' has staff posing as voters and may wrongly implicate US citizens.
What the Whistleblower Alleges
A federal whistleblower's statement released Monday alleges that a last-ditch Trump administration effort to hunt for noncitizen voters ahead of November's elections is requiring federal employees to misrepresent themselves on state voter lookup tools in a way that likely violates state laws.
The anonymous, nearly 30-page disclosure concerns a Department of Homeland Security probe known as the 'Unlawful Voter Initiative.'
It warns the program also asks employees to create federal law enforcement records about voters based on unreliable data, which could potentially wrongly implicate U.S. citizens in official documentation that could spur further investigation.
Who Released the Disclosure and How It Was Built
Democratic Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer of New York and Democratic Sen. Alex Padilla of California, the ranking member of a Senate committee overseeing federal elections, published the disclosure Monday.
The account was produced by the watchdog group Democracy Defenders Fund, which said it represents the whistleblower as a client and that the person remains anonymous because of 'an extreme fear of retaliation.'
The disclosure features screenshots and transcripts of a DHS training for a group of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services staffers, who it says were forced in late August to drop their other work, complete a less than two-hour training session, and begin running DHS-provided lists of individuals through state voter registration systems to find 'unlawful voters.'
Quotas, Minutes-Long Reviews, and Posing as Voters
The whistleblower contends that agents have been asked to review 40 individuals per day, giving them about 12 minutes to determine whether each person is a legal voter and to create federal records of anyone who is not.
According to the account, Citizenship and Immigration Services employees were directed to pose as individual voters to access state voter records, working around a lack of data from the states.
Some states, such as Virginia, explicitly limit their voter lookup tools to individuals who attest under penalty of law that they are looking up their own records.
In other states, like California, personally identifiable information such as a driver's license number or partial Social Security number is needed for such lookups.
The whistleblower said that when officers raised concerns about liability for searching the tools against state guidance, agency leaders told them to proceed anyway.
Why This Is Surprising
The allegations land amid a broader administration push targeting noncitizen voting, even as research shows voting by people who are not citizens is extremely rare.
The scale and methods described — short training, daily quotas, and impersonating voters on state systems — would represent an unusual federal approach to election verification.
The potential for U.S. citizens to be wrongly implicated based on data the senators describe as unreliable adds a further dimension, since DHS data on voters can differ from state records.
The Political Fight and DHS's Defense
Padilla and Schumer said Monday the initiative was an example of President Donald Trump attempting to interfere in elections and that the short timelines would impede officials from conducting proper investigations.
'We just got more proof of Trump's vile schemes to rig our elections,' Schumer told reporters at a news conference, adding that 'the lengths Trump will go to cheat, lie and steal in this upcoming election are simply beyond the pale.'
The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
A DHS spokesperson said the department is 'laser focused on prosecuting and removing aliens who vote,' that it accessed publicly available data from states' voter rolls and cross-referenced them with known aliens in its systems, and that 'far from being rushed or untrained, these investigative efforts are conducted diligently and professionally.'
What Comes Next
Schumer and Padilla on Sunday sent a letter to DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin requesting more information about the initiative and demanding that it be stopped.
The stakes are high ahead of November's midterm elections: if the whistleblower's account is accurate, federal records created on the basis of unreliable data could trigger investigations of eligible voters, while the alleged use of state lookup tools under false pretenses could expose federal employees to liability under state laws like Virginia's.
The administration's wider campaign also includes pushing for the U.S. Postal Service to send mail ballots only to voters verified as U.S. citizens, and a Justice Department effort to sue for the release of detailed voter data in 30 states and the District of Columbia, which has not yet succeeded in those cases.
Sources
- dailynews.com › DHS voter probe may break state laws and wrongly implicate US citizens, whistleblower alleges
- dailygazette.com › DHS voter probe may break state laws and wrongly implicate US citizens, whistleblower alleges
- goshennews.com › DHS voter probe may break state laws and wrongly implicate US citizens, whistleblower alleges
- ottumwacourier.com › DHS voter probe may break state laws and wrongly implicate US citizens, whistleblower alleges
- couriernews.com › DHS voter probe may break state laws and wrongly implicate US citizens, whistleblower alleges