Broadway Flop Gets Brand-New Life in Seoul Staging
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Theater
- Musicals
- Broadway
- A Tale Of Two Cities
Korea JoongAng Daily reports 'A Tale of Two Cities' returned to Seoul with an all-new production its creator wants to take back to Broadway.
A Twelve-Year Gap Ends With a Rebuilt Musical
The Korea JoongAng Daily reports that Jill Santoriello's musical "A Tale of Two Cities" opened Wednesday at the Gwanglim Arts Center's BBCH Hall in Gangnam, the show's first Korean run in 12 years.
Where the 2012, 2013 and 2014 Korean runs were replicas of the Broadway production, Santoriello told the paper this version is "all brand new" — new staging, new projected scenery replacing heavy sets, and three songs new to Korea.
Why the Broadway History Is So Striking
According to Korea JoongAng Daily, the 2008 Broadway production the old replicas copied lasted barely two months: it opened at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre on Sept. 18, 2008 — three days after Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy — and closed Nov. 9 after 60 performances.
Award nominations, including an Outer Critics Circle nod and three Drama Desk nominations, arrived the next year with no tickets left to sell. Santoriello said she never expected a future beyond Broadway until Japanese and Korean producers picked the show up within a year.
The Score Changes Most of All
Korea JoongAng Daily details the musical changes: three second-act songs new to Korea, including "One More Time" by Santoriello and "Never Say Goodbye" by Frank Wildhorn, both written for Toho's 2025 Tokyo revival, plus Wildhorn's "I'll Die for Love," premiering in this production.
Shownote's staging swaps much of the heavy scenery for projected backdrops. Santoriello told the paper the original actor-hauled set is what she would leave in New York, and that any future Broadway copy should be of the Seoul one.
A Rare Triple-Threat Writer, and a Parallel First
The paper notes Santoriello wrote the book, music and lyrics herself — still unusual on Broadway, and rarer for women — a feat she says has otherwise happened mainly with Dickens musicals like "Oliver!" and "The Mystery of Edwin Drood."
The same week, Maui Now reports a different kind of stage first: "The Epic Tale of Hiʻiaka: The Hawaiian Goddess," the first Broadway-style musical drawn from a Hawaiian moʻolelo, opens Dec. 5 at Ko Olina after ten years of development, with Kumu Hula Patrick Makuakāne and Roslyn Catracchia writing book, music and lyrics together.
Stakes, Tickets and What Comes Next
The Korea JoongAng Daily reports Santoriello's Broadway producers have been discussing a revival, and she wants the Seoul version to be the template — ideally with a movie star as Sydney Carton. The Seoul run continues through Feb. 8, 2027, with tickets from 80,000 to 160,000 won ($59 to $119).
Meanwhile Playbill reports the "Cats: The Jellicle Ball" cast album, delayed last month, is now set for Feb. 12 on Atlantic Records, with "Mungojerrie and Rumpleteazer" already streaming — more evidence that short-lived 2026 Broadway productions keep finding afterlives.