Fair Work Commission Rejects Pineapple Pizza Chef's Claim
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Food
- Pineapple Pizza
- Fair Work Commission
- Chefs
The Fair Work Commission has rejected an Italian chef's dismissal challenge after he refused three times to put pineapple on pizza.
The refusal that made headlines
Italian chef Davide Tamburella was fired from La Costa Restaurant and Bar in Brisbane's Fortitude Valley on May 20 after he declined an instruction to add pineapple to pizzas, which he considered an insult to his Italian culture.
According to The Economic Times, he had told his employer to look into the cultural significance many Italians attach to keeping pineapple off pizza. The request came from a customer celebrating a birthday at the restaurant, and owner Elliot Ingram says it was a reasonable one.
As both outlets report, this was the third time in four years that Tamburella had refused a similar direction.
Why the claim was knocked back
The Fair Work Commission's ruling, published on November 3 and reported by both ABC News and The Economic Times, did not resolve the question of whether the dismissal was fair.
Commissioner Jennifer Hunt dismissed Tamburella's application because it was filed more than 21 days after his dismissal, and the commission did not find exceptional circumstances to allow an extension of time.
According to The Economic Times, the commission therefore made no final determination on his allegations about the reasons behind his dismissal.
Not just the pineapple, says the owner
La Costa owner Elliot Ingram says the pineapple incident was not the 'one defining factor' behind the firing.
In its ruling, the commission noted that reasons for the dismissal also included Tamburella's 'acknowledged use of inappropriate language' and 'ongoing concerns regarding leadership behaviour, professionalism'.
The Economic Times reports that Ingram also cited the chef's response to management instructions, his conduct during service, and his interactions with colleagues, and maintained that a workplace injury — Tamburella fractured two bones in his right hand striking a metal handrail — and his workers' compensation claim played no role in the decision.
Hawaiian debate meets Australian hospitality
The case has become a lightning rod for the eternal pineapple-on-pizza debate, played out on industrial-relations turf.
Ingram told ABC News that 'being in Australia, having pineapple on pizza is very common', noting that Italians are very traditional about their food, 'but at the end of the day we're not in Italy, we're in Australia.'
According to The Economic Times, Tamburella has already moved on, now listed on LinkedIn as head chef at Don Gino in West End.