Judge Blocks ICE Arrests at Immigration Courts Nationwide
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- US News
- Immigration
- Courts
A federal judge issued a nationwide injunction barring ICE from arresting migrants at immigration courts, calling the policy arbitrary.
Nationwide injunction against courthouse arrests
U.S. District Judge P. Casey Pitts of the Northern District of California issued a nationwide injunction Tuesday blocking the Trump administration from arresting migrants at immigration courts.
In a 71-page decision, he wrote that policies by Immigration and Customs Enforcement and the Executive Office for Immigration Review were "arbitrary and capricious" and violated the Administrative Procedures Act, adding that the agencies failed to provide reasoned explanations for their actions.
The ruling halts a practice that drew scrutiny after widely reported arrests at courthouses, including in New York City, where migrants were often detained after their deportation cases were dismissed.
Why the ruling is a reversal
The decision is a sharp setback for an enforcement strategy that expanded courthouse arrests beyond the prior norm.
Attorneys told ABC News that the administration had been using case dismissals to detain people at immigration courts and place them into expedited removal without letting them fight their cases, whereas ICE historically prioritized arresting people considered public risks or with certain criminal charges.
The government's own legal footing also collapsed: the DOJ acknowledged in a New York case that an ICE memo it had relied on does not even apply to civil immigration enforcement in or near immigration courts, a concession the judge cited as showing "a complete lack of decision making."
The administration fights back
The Justice Department tried to narrow the request to only the Northern District of California rather than a nationwide block, but the court sided with a sweeping remedy.
Meanwhile, the administration is pressing its immigration agenda on other fronts: according to Hindustan Times, Labor Department Inspector General Anthony D'Esposito signaled a "big week" of new action on foreign labor visa programs, and President Trump extended restrictions on certain H-1B workers until September 21, 2027.
What comes next for migrants and courts
For now, the injunction applies across the United States, meaning migrants attending deportation hearings can no longer expect arrest at the courthouse door — a significant shift, since dismissal of a case is often a positive outcome that allows an individual to pursue asylum or other legal relief.