Critics Call 'Remain' Shyamalan's Best Since 'Signs'
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Film
- M Night Shyamalan
- Remain
- First Reactions
First reactions from Beyond Fest hail M. Night Shyamalan's 'Remain' as his finest work since 'Signs,' praising Gyllenhaal and Dynevor's chemistry.
What the first reactions say
Following the surprise Beyond Fest screening, The Hollywood Reporter rounds up a wave of overwhelmingly positive social-media reactions to 'Remain.'
Attendees called it 'scary as hell and heartbreaking,' with one fan deeming it 'a masterpiece' and 'a perfect companion to The Sixth Sense for a double feature.'
GeekTyrant notes the reactions describe a film that is 'heartbreaking' and 'scary as hell' — an unusual pairing for a supernatural love story.
Why the praise is a reversal
Shyamalan's films typically divide audiences, so GeekTyrant calls the uniformly warm response 'certainly encouraging.'
Reaction posters quoted by The Hollywood Reporter placed 'Remain' among his very best: one called it 'his best work since SIGNS and THE VILLAGE,' another dubbed it 'his Vertigo' and a 'total return to form,' and a third named it his favorite Shyamalan 'this decade.'
That kind of consensus-breaking enthusiasm is rare for a director whose premieres usually spark argument.
The evidence on screen
The Hollywood Reporter's roundup credits the film's VistaVision photography, James Newton Howard's 'sensation' score, and 'ELECTRIC' chemistry between Jake Gyllenhaal and Phoebe Dynevor.
GeekTyrant's quoted reactions praise Gyllenhaal for selling 'the classic M Night awkwardness' and call the film his funniest yet, mixing romance, comedy and horror. One reaction describes 'What Lies Beneath with more kissing.'
The stakes for Shyamalan and Warners
According to The Hollywood Reporter, Shyamalan confessed earlier this year that 'Remain' was 'my highest-testing movie of my career,' and the film is his second consecutive project for Warner Bros. after 2024's 'Trap,' which the outlet reports earned $84 million worldwide on a $30 million budget.
What comes next
Per The Hollywood Reporter, 'Remain' opens February 5, 2027, after being moved from its original October 23, 2026 date to sit closer to Valentine's Day — a scheduling signal the outlet reads as bullishness from Shyamalan and Warners.
GeekTyrant notes the pairing began, in Shyamalan's words, with questions of 'What scares you? What moves you?
What stays with you?' Whether the festival goodwill carries into a wide, meme-conscious theatrical audience is the next test.