25 States Sue EPA Over Repealed Power Plant Carbon Limits
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Climate
- Epa
- Carbon Standards
- Litigation
- Wisconsin
A 25-member state and city coalition petitioned the D.C. Circuit on Oct. 1 to overturn the EPA's repeal of the 2024 Carbon Pollution Standards.
The lawsuit: what happened
On Oct. 1, a coalition of 25 states, cities and counties filed a petition for review in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, asking the court to overturn the EPA's repeal of the 2024 Carbon Pollution Standards for coal- and gas-fired power plants.
The Wisconsin Department of Justice joined the challenge, which includes attorneys general from 20 states and the District of Columbia, Pennsylvania's governor, the mayors of New York City and Chicago, and the City and County of Denver.
Why the fight goes beyond the repeal
The coalition also notified the EPA of its intent to sue over what it called the agency's continued failure to regulate greenhouse gas pollution from existing natural gas power plants, including 'peaker' plants that run during high demand.
According to the Daily Dodge, the Wisconsin DOJ says the EPA issued standards for new gas-fired plants more than a decade ago but never set similar limits for existing ones, and that many peaker plants sit in low-income communities and communities of color.
The legal arguments
The petition argues the EPA unlawfully repealed the pollution standards without adequately considering alternatives or the health and economic costs of allowing additional emissions. The groups also allege the agency failed to properly calculate the costs of repealing the rule.
Wisconsin Attorney General Josh Kaul said the administration had chosen 'more wildfire smoke, more extreme weather, more harms to people's health' and more profits for the fossil fuel industry, adding that the EPA should be protecting communities from pollution rather than removing safeguards.
The stakes for Wisconsin and beyond
According to the Wisconsin DOJ, power plants produce about one-quarter of U.S. carbon dioxide emissions, and eliminating pollution limits could bring more frequent heat waves, stronger storms, flooding and wildfire smoke.
The department cited a 2020 University of Wisconsin report finding extreme heat kills more Wisconsin residents than other weather disasters combined, and a 2024 Center for Climate Integrity estimate that Wisconsin communities could face more than $16 billion in costs to protect themselves from climate impacts.
What comes next
The case now heads to the D.C. Circuit, the same court that routinely reviews major federal environmental rules, where judges will weigh whether the repeal process met legal requirements.
A separate notice of intent to sue over existing gas plants could follow if the EPA does not move to regulate them.