Vulcan Fails, 40 Amazon Leo Satellites Lost
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Space
- Rocket Launch
- Ula Vulcan
- Amazon Leo
ULA's Vulcan Centaur suffered an anomaly 10 minutes after liftoff, losing 40 Amazon Leo satellites in ULA's first total mission failure since 2006.
What happened
United Launch Alliance's Vulcan Centaur lifted off from Cape Canaveral Space Force Station at 12:40 p.m. ET on Nov. 15, carrying 40 satellites for Amazon's Leo broadband constellation.
Ten minutes into the flight, ULA confirmed the rocket "suffered an anomaly" and failed to deliver the Amazon mission to orbit. The company said it had no specific data yet to understand what occurred, and later wrote that "today, we did not meet that standard" of mission success.
Why it is a first and an upset
This was the first total mission failure for United Launch Alliance since its formation in 2006 through the merger of Boeing and Lockheed Martin's rocket divisions.
It is also a reversal for a rocket meant to prove itself: the flight was Vulcan's return-to-flight after a nine-month pause, and the solid-rocket-booster nozzle problem that caused earlier trouble appeared to be fixed, with all six SRBs performing well before a new, different failure took down the booster stage.
The evidence in the telemetry
Ars Technica reports, citing multiple sources, that the anomaly occurred in the booster stage, not the Centaur V upper stage or the solid rocket boosters.
The twin Blue Origin BE-4 main engines, which were supposed to shut down just shy of the five-minute mark, kept firing for at least 30 additional seconds — an overburn that could indicate underperformance.
ULA's telemetry-driven animation showed Vulcan begin to spin after booster shutdown, continuing through Centaur separation as the RL10 engines vectored thrust in an apparent recovery attempt.
The stakes for Amazon and the Pentagon
The loss is expected to ground Vulcan for an indefinite period.
Amazon has 37 more Vulcan launches reserved to build its planned 3,292-satellite Leo constellation, of which only 396 satellites are in orbit; Amazon officials told Ars Technica in October that it had enough satellites to start initial commercial service by year's end.
Vulcan also carries roughly half of upcoming US military national security launches, and NASA recently selected ULA's Centaur upper stage for future SLS Moon missions, so investigators must clear the Centaur V as well.
What comes next
ULA says engineers will investigate to "find the cause, determine the appropriate corrective action, and return to flight as quickly as possible," promising full transparency with customers.
If a BE-4 engine was at fault, Ars Technica notes it could delay Blue Origin's New Glenn, which uses a similar engine and whose pad is already offline after a May ground-test explosion.
Amazon's remaining options include 10 reserved Falcon 9 launches and Arianespace's Ariane 6, while NASA's administrator said the agency is "in your corner" to assist the investigation.