UN Backs Equal Earth Map Showing Africa's True Size

The UN General Assembly voted 164 to 1, with the US alone opposed, to endorse replacing the Mercator map with the more accurate Equal Earth projection.

@sharedot

UN Backs Equal Earth Map Showing Africa's True Size

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • World
  • United Nations
  • Africa
  • Cartography

The UN General Assembly voted 164 to 1, with the US alone opposed, to endorse replacing the Mercator map with the more accurate Equal Earth projection.

A Landslide Vote to Correct the Map

The UN General Assembly on Friday endorsed a non-binding 'Correct the Map' resolution encouraging governments and institutions to replace the 16th-century Mercator projection with the Equal Earth projection.

The measure, sponsored by Togo and backed by the 55-member African Union, passed with 164 member states in favor. Only the United States voted against it, while six countries — Serbia, Estonia, Georgia, Lithuania, Moldova and Ukraine — abstained.

France and the United Kingdom were among the supporters. The resolution does not ban Mercator or mandate a replacement; it only encourages the switch, the UN said in its report.

Why Mercator Shrinks Africa

The Mercator projection, created by Flemish cartographer Gerardus Mercator to help European navigators at sea, distorts landmasses by enlarging regions near the poles — such as North America and Greenland — while shrinking areas near the equator.

On some Mercator maps, Africa and Greenland appear roughly the same size, though Africa is actually about 14 times larger.

Geographers say the traditional map is useful only for navigation; Syracuse University geography professor Mark Monmonier told the Associated Press that 'outside of that very narrow navigation application, there is no point in using it.'

The 2018 Equal Earth projection follows the Earth's curvature and shows continents in their true proportions.

A US Vote Against a Symbolic Shift

The lone US vote against the measure drew attention given the resolution's non-binding nature.

According to NewsOne, the American representative, Yaryna Ferencevych, deputy US representative to the UN Economic and Social Council, argued the resolution went beyond fixing map proportions, calling it part of a 'radical ideological project' and criticizing its references to reparations and 'cognitive justice' as undermining the UN's credibility.

The UN's own reporting, cited by NewsOne, tied the Mercator distortions to a 'symbolic minimization' of Africa, characterizing the correction as an act of 'cognitive justice and memorial reparation.'

Eastern Europe's Abstentions Explained

Six countries abstained, and the pack points to a territorial concern.

According to NewsOne, citing the Kyiv Post, Ukraine was sympathetic to the broader goal of accuracy but warned that adopting Equal Earth without safeguards could create ambiguity over Russian-occupied Ukrainian territory depicted on some versions of the map — for instance, one version depicted temporarily occupied Crimea as separate from the rest of the country.

Serbia, Estonia, Georgia, Lithuania and Moldova joined Ukraine in abstaining, per the Associated Press.

The Stakes: Education and Perception

Supporters argue the distortions shape political and economic perceptions of Africa, minimizing the continent's size, resources, population and development potential.

Togo's Foreign Minister Robert Dussey told delegates before the vote that 'maps shape our understanding of the world' and guide education and collective perceptions.

Africa No Filter, a lead campaigner, said: 'We want to see accurate maps in schools, textbooks, newsrooms, businesses and on the digital platforms billions of people use every day.'

French Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot, who said France is abandoning Mercator entirely, wrote that changing the map doesn't change the world, 'but correcting a representation that distorts it is already an act of truth.'

What Comes Next

The African Union adopted the Equal Earth projection earlier this year, and the UN vote is expected to push schools, publishers and digital platforms toward equal-area maps.

Commentary from African outlets gathered by allAfrica suggests the decision could trigger a rethink of how geography is taught in countries such as Tanzania.

Not everyone sees material change ahead: according to Vanguard, former Central Bank of Nigeria deputy governor Kingsley Moghalu welcomed the resolution but argued that correcting Africa's map won't by itself bring prosperity.

Because the resolution is non-binding, adoption in classrooms and software will depend on governments, educators and technology companies acting on the encouragement.

Sources

  1. allafrica.com › UN Votes to Adopt New World Map That Shows Africa's True Size
  2. nbcphiladelphia.com › UN General Assembly endorses a new world map that shows more accurately Africa's size
  3. newsone.com › US Votes Against UN-Endorsed New World Map To Correct Africa's Size

More on World