Alex Van Halen Calls Sammy Hagar 'A Complete Idiot'

Alex Van Halen branded former bandmate Sammy Hagar a 'complete idiot' in a new interview, and Hagar responded by calling the insult 'unnecessary' and urging peace.

@sharedot

Alex Van Halen Calls Sammy Hagar 'A Complete Idiot'

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Entertainment
  • Music
  • Van Halen

Alex Van Halen branded former bandmate Sammy Hagar a 'complete idiot' in a new interview, and Hagar responded by calling the insult 'unnecessary' and urging peace.

What Happened

Asked about Hagar's 2011 memoir "Red: My Uncensored Life in Rock," the drummer dismissed it outright: "I don't know what he wrote, and I don't wanna know. Peace already."

According to Guitar Player, the same interview saw Alex praise David Lee Roth's "Crazy From the Heart" as "quite entertaining," a pointed contrast between the band's two classic-era frontmen.

Why It's Surprising

What makes the timing striking is that Hagar had recently extended olive branches.

According to Fox News, Hagar and Michael Anthony reached out to Alex "a dozen times" before the 2024 "Best of All Worlds" tour and received no response, and Hagar told Rolling Stone in April 2025 that the two had not spoken in 21 years.

USA Today adds that earlier in 2026, Hagar said he would "drop just about everything, except for my live shows" if Alex called about unreleased Eddie Van Halen music. The jab came anyway, undeterred by Hagar's public overtures.

The Evidence

The details align across the pack's three reports, though some single-source details deserve attribution. Fox News and USA Today agree that Hagar fronted Van Halen from 1985 until tensions erupted in 1996, reunited for a 2004 tour, and that Hagar's book discussed Eddie Van Halen's alcoholism.

Fox News reports that Alex told Billboard his 2024 memoir "Brothers" would focus on the original lineup, saying "What happened after Dave left is not the same band."

Fox News also cites Hagar's theory that Alex resents that he and Anthony are still performing Van Halen songs while Alex, who has health problems, no longer plays drums. Guitar Player reports Hagar called that memoir's omission of his era "blasphemy."

The Stakes

This is more than rock-star bickering — it determines what Van Halen's legacy looks like after Eddie Van Halen's death from throat cancer in October 2020 at age 65.

USA Today notes that when the band entered the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame in 2007, only Hagar and Michael Anthony attended, as Eddie was in rehab. Hagar's "Best of All Worlds" tour, with Anthony, Joe Satriani and Jason Bonham, is now the closest live link to the band's catalog.

According to Guitar Player, Hagar argues that with "frickin' Mike Anthony's in the band," fans get music "no one will ever hear again" otherwise — while Alex insists that lineup isn't "doing the band justice."

What Comes Next

Neither side shows signs of backing down, but both have framed the path forward. Alex's representatives did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital's request for comment, so the drummer has not publicly elaborated beyond the interview.

Hagar, for his part, has compared the rift to Pink Floyd's David Gilmour and Roger Waters, telling Classic Rock: "I will never play with Alex Van Halen again... They're negative people."

USA Today notes Hagar has since expressed regret about the "angst" in his 2011 book, written while he was angry about being "thrown out of the band ruthlessly."

With Hagar calling for "peace already" and Alex offering no comment, the likeliest next move is silence — unless unreleased Eddie Van Halen music changes the calculus.

Sources

  1. foxnews.com › Alex Van Halen calls Sammy Hagar 'a complete idiot' as decades-long feud deepens
  2. guitarplayer.com › Alex Van Halen slams the former Van Halen singer in the latest volley of their ongoing feud
  3. usatoday.com › Alex Van Halen calls ex-bandmate Sammy Hagar a 'complete idiot,' Hagar reacts

More on Entertainment