Gyllenhaal Ditches AI Marilyn After Failed Experiment

Maggie Gyllenhaal said at a Venice symposium she scrapped AI footage of Dakota Johnson as Marilyn Monroe because the human performance moved her more.

@sharedot

Gyllenhaal Ditches AI Marilyn After Failed Experiment

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Entertainment
  • Venice Film Festival
  • AI In Film
  • Maggie Gyllenhaal

Maggie Gyllenhaal said at a Venice symposium she scrapped AI footage of Dakota Johnson as Marilyn Monroe because the human performance moved her more.

What Happened in Venice

Maggie Gyllenhaal told The Future of Creativity event at the Venice Film Festival that she abandoned AI-generated video planned for her short film 'Flesh Impact,' which imagines Marilyn Monroe at 100.

According to FOX 26, carrying AFP reporting, commissioners on the project asked her to use AI trained on licensed Monroe films to transform Dakota Johnson into the icon, and she agreed to try.

Both FOX 26 and Screen Daily report her verdict: 'It fundamentally did not work,' and she threw the footage away because Johnson playing Monroe was 'so much more moving, human and alive.'

Why the Reversal Is Surprising

The reversal cuts against the aggressive push of AI video tools at directors as a cost-saving alternative to acting that FOX 26 describes from the festival.

Gyllenhaal also revealed a new licensing paradigm she rejected: someone she respected asked her to have actors who trust her hand over their likenesses for AI reproduction, which she called 'a completely and absolutely different paradigm than how I think, how I work.'

Screen Daily adds her argument that collaboration with actors like Jessie Buckley — 'bouncing off the world' — is impossible to replicate, making her public rejection of finished AI footage a notable stand.

Clooney's Warning on Jobs

Screen Daily reports George Clooney predicted AI would revolutionize filmmaking: 'You'll be able to make a film on your phone that costs the studio a couple of 100 million dollars.'

Both Screen Daily and FOX 26 quote him warning that 'a lot of people are going to get replaced, not just actors, but crew members, visual effects supervisors.'

Gyllenhaal framed the same economics at the panel, asking who would fund a $10 million film the old way if a commercial-quality movie could be made for $40,000 or $4 million.

Doubts Versus the Hype

According to FOX 26, Signal president Meredith Whittaker warned that AI is controlled by a handful of billionaires and urged the Venice audience 'don't buy the hype.'

Screen Daily notes panelists including Darren Walker said audiences may distinguish human-made films, with Gen Z returning to theatres and live events, while others flagged AI's concentration in companies like Google, OpenAI and X. FOX 26 reports festival director Alberto Barbera struck a more optimistic note, saying the technology lets directors achieve things not previously possible, and notes Venice programmed the fully AI-made documentary 'Be Brave' about Diesel founder Renzo Rosso.

The Stakes and What Comes Next

The economics behind these debates remain in flux.

ROI-NJ's Garden State Greenlight podcast reports that New Jersey's film tax credit is helping attract productions, with Withum advisors Alex Holderbaum and Conor Barnes explaining how filmmakers qualify and what CPAs contribute beyond incentives, including tax planning, business structure and licensing agreements.

Screen Daily reports Clooney widened the debate beyond jobs, citing fabricated AI video of himself with President Obama and asking how audiences would discern a fake video of Putin announcing a nuclear strike.

Sources

  1. fox26medford.com › Director Maggie Gyllenhaal ditched AI for Marilyn Monroe film
  2. screendaily.com › George Clooney, Maggie Gyllenhaal warn of risks to film industry from AI
  3. roi-nj.com › Garden State Greenlight: Withum's Conor Barnes and Alex Holderbaum on N.J.'s film tax credit

More on Entertainment