Rachael Kirkconnell Refuses to Settle After Matt James Split

Rachael Kirkconnell says she'd rather stay single than settle after her split from Matt James.

@sharedot

Rachael Kirkconnell Refuses to Settle After Matt James Split

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • Celebrity
  • Bachelor Nation
  • Rachael Kirkconnell
  • Matt James

Rachael Kirkconnell says she'd rather stay single than settle after her split from Matt James.

What Kirkconnell Told the Podcast

On the Thursday, October 22 episode of iHeartRadio's 'Scrubbing In' podcast with hosts Becca Tilley and Tanya Rad, Rachael Kirkconnell, 30, said she is 'very content' with herself even as her friends marry, get engaged, and have children.

Us Weekly reports she told the hosts, 'I do want that, and I do think that life is probably so much more sweet when you are living it with someone,' while stressing she would 'rather be single' than be in a relationship that isn't like her friends' happy marriages.

'I'm not going to settle at this point,' she said, adding she 'can be OK being alone' rather than in a bad or unhappy relationship.

Why the Declaration Surprises Bachelor Nation

The statement is a striking reversal of tone for a star who spent four years with Matt James after his 2021 season of The Bachelor, only to be allegedly blindsided when James abruptly announced their breakup in January 2025 while she was on a plane home from Japan.

Us Weekly notes Kirkconnell told the magazine in March 2025 that the split felt 'out of nowhere' and that she suspected James had some regret about how it was handled.

Where she once called the breakup 'a blessing in disguise,' she is now publicly vowing never to settle — and joking she might 'have like a bunch of animals and I'll be fine, who knows?'

The Evidence: No Drive to DM

Yahoo Entertainment, carrying the Us Weekly report, highlights Kirkconnell's explanation for why she has not dived back into dating: 'I don't even have the drive to DM someone because I'm like, Well, I don't actually know them.'

She said she is 'not attracted to what I see on Instagram in any way' and has never wanted to pursue someone based only on photos or videos of them catching a touchdown.

Us Weekly also reports she addressed her status with Shane Parton, who appeared on Taylor Frankie Paul's unaired Bachelorette season, calling him 'great' and 'one of my good friends' after recent outings together.

The Stakes and What Comes Next

For devoted Bachelor Nation followers, the stakes are whether Kirkconnell will step back into the franchise orbit or chart a new path as a content creator on her own terms.

Per Us Weekly, she voiced both vulnerability and resolve in an earlier interview, admitting she is 'scared for the future sometimes' and does not know if her person is out there, while insisting she is 'really enjoying' her independence.

With her friends' marriages as the standard she says she will not compromise below, the next chapter — a friend in Shane Parton, no interest in Instagram-flirting — remains hers to define, and fans will be watching.

Sources

  1. usmagazine.com › Rachael Kirkconnell Says She Refuses to 'Settle' for a 'Bad Relationship' After Matt James Split
  2. yahoo.com › Rachael Kirkconnell Says She Refuses to 'Settle' for a 'Bad Relationship' After Matt James Split

More on Celebrity