Xbox Survey Floats Pulling Minecraft From PlayStation and Nintendo
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Gaming
- Minecraft
- Xbox
- Playstation
- Nintendo
An Xbox survey asks fans how they'd feel if Minecraft left PlayStation and Nintendo entirely, including ending updates for existing versions.
What happened: a survey asks the unthinkable
According to Windows Central, as reported by GAMINGbible and GamesRadar+, Microsoft has sent surveys to some Xbox Insider members asking how they would feel if all future Xbox titles became console exclusives.
The most startling hypothetical names Minecraft directly: the question reportedly says that for Minecraft only, existing titles would no longer be available for purchase on PlayStation or Nintendo consoles, and would not receive any new content updates.
It is a survey, not an announcement — but the question itself is a striking signal of how far Microsoft is willing to test the waters on exclusivity.
Why it is a reversal of Xbox's recent strategy
The surprise is how sharply this would break with recent practice. As GamesRadar+ notes, after buying Activision Blizzard and Bethesda, Microsoft spent a period acting almost like a third-party publisher, bringing nearly all of its games to PS5.
Under new Xbox CEO Asha Sharma the strategy shifted again, with Gears of War: E-Day kept as an Xbox and PC title despite reports that a PS5 port was nearly complete.
Now, GAMINGbible reports, the survey asks whether even Minecraft — the ultimate cross-platform game — could go exclusive, with Call of Duty, The Elder Scrolls and Fallout also name-dropped in the hypothetical.
The evidence: what the questions cover
GamesRadar+ reports that the surveys sent to Xbox Insider members asked where players would play certain titles — or whether they would play them at all if they were not on PS5 or Switch 2 — and reportedly included questions about Fallout, The Elder Scrolls, and Hideo Kojima's Physint, which Xbox Game Studios now publishes after Sony cancelled it.
The final question asked players to imagine every Xbox game was exclusive, with one carve-out: Call of Duty is excluded because Microsoft is legally required to release it on other platforms until at least 2033.
The stakes for millions of players
Minecraft is arguably the most popular game in the world, as GAMINGbible recounts: officially launched in 2011 after a 2009 beta, present on every console generation since, with spin-offs, a Netflix series and a movie.
GamesRadar+ adds hard numbers to the concern — Minecraft on Switch has sold over 4 million physical copies in Japan alone, the PS4 version had more than 17 million players as of 2019, and the game has sold over 425 million copies while attracting 300,000 new players a day.
Ending purchases and updates on PlayStation and Nintendo would also fracture cross-platform play, hitting younger players hardest.
Why the timing is so sensitive
The hypothetical lands just weeks before the biggest launch in gaming.
PCMag reports that Grand Theft Auto VI arrives on November 19 on PS5 and Xbox Series X, priced at $79.99 for the Standard edition and $99.99 for the Ultimate edition on both platforms, with PCMag's Jordan Minor concluding the PS5 — from $599.99 for the all-digital model versus $749.99 for the digital Series X — is the best-value way to play.
If Microsoft were ever to pull flagship titles from other platforms, console-buying decisions like this one would become far more fraught, and GamesRadar+ argues that even floating the removal of Minecraft from other consoles is 'so brazenly a bad decision that even being floated is concerning.'
What comes next
For now, nothing is announced. Both GAMINGbible and GamesRadar+ stress that the survey is hypothetical and does not confirm an immediate shift in strategy for Minecraft, The Elder Scrolls, Fallout or Call of Duty — Microsoft has made no such announcement.
But the fact the questions exist suggests Microsoft is at least exploring how players would feel about a more exclusive future, as GAMINGbible puts it.
With Gears of War: E-Day already Xbox-and-PC only and Fable previously confirmed for a PS5 launch, the next survey results — and any quiet strategy shifts behind them — are worth watching closely. GAMINGbible says it will update readers as more is learned.