Holmes Doc 'You Can See Everything' Edges to First No. 1

A24's Elizabeth Holmes documentary took its first No. 1 in its third weekend, edging 'Clayface' by roughly $200,000 in a sleepy Halloween frame.

@sharedot

Holmes Doc 'You Can See Everything' Edges to First No. 1

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Film
  • Box Office
  • You Can See Everything
  • Elizabeth Holmes
  • Clayface

A24's Elizabeth Holmes documentary took its first No. 1 in its third weekend, edging 'Clayface' by roughly $200,000 in a sleepy Halloween frame.

A Documentary Takes the Top Spot

Per studio estimates reported Sunday by AP (via ABC News and ClickOnDetroit), A24's Elizabeth Holmes documentary "You Can See Everything" led the North American box office with $10.6 million from 2,655 locations in its third weekend, the first time it has hit No. 1.

The Warner Bros./DC villain origin story "Clayface" trailed by just $200,684 at $10.4 million. Hollywood Outbreak reports the race is so tight the No. 1 spot could still flip once final figures arrive Monday.

Why a Three-Hour Doc Winning Is a Shock

For film watchers the surprise is the film itself: a nearly three-hour documentary about a jailed Theranos founder, co-directed by comedian Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, out-drawing a gory Batman release.

According to Hollywood Outbreak, the directors put more than three years into the project, which follows Holmes and her family for a month before she began an 11-year prison sentence in 2023 for fraud and conspiracy.

Yahoo reports the film is generating major Oscars buzz, including entry into the best picture conversation.

The Numbers Behind the Upset

The economics are the part fans keep repeating. ABC News reports "You Can See Everything" has made $63.9 million to date against a reported production budget of $7 million.

"Clayface," by contrast, fell 57% in its second weekend to $44.1 million domestic against a reported $44 million budget, with Hollywood Outbreak adding roughly $83 million worldwide. A Sundance-style counter-programming story has flipped the usual blockbuster math in a holiday frame.

Amanda Seyfried's Cameo and the Awards Chatter

Yahoo reports that Amanda Seyfried — who starred as Holmes in the mini-series "The Dropout" — has sparked awards chatter with a surprise cameo in "You Can See Everything."

Yahoo also notes the Theranos scandal previously fueled a book, multiple podcasts and that series, giving the documentary a rare layer of intertextual appeal: audiences arriving with years of the story already in their heads, and leaving to spread the word.

A Sleepy Halloween Frame

The backdrop matters too. Analyst David A. Gross of Franchise Entertainment Research, quoted by Yahoo and Media Play News, said "Clayface" and "Wildwood" would do significantly better if kids, teens and young adults weren't focused on costumes, candy and trick-or-treating.

Media Play News adds Gross wrote that major distributors won't compete with a Halloween falling on Friday and Saturday nights.

What Comes Next

Final tallies land Monday, November 2, and with a gap of about $200,000, Hollywood Outbreak argues it is smarter to wait before crowning a winner.

Rest of the chart, per AP: "Wildwood" held third at $7.5 million ($25.9 million total), "Wicker" fourth at $4.1 million, and "Street Fighter" fifth at $3.2 million.

ABC News lists "Resident Evil" and "Other Mommy" next at $2.5 million apiece, while Yahoo's top-10 includes "BTS World Tour - Sao Paulo (Live)" at $2.8 million and "Heart of the Beast" at $1.6 million — Media Play News separately reports Brad Pitt's "Heart of the Beast" added $5.2 million internationally.

Even in a slump, AP notes the domestic box office is up over 17% from last year at nearly $8.5 billion.

Sources

  1. abcnews.com › 'You Can See Everything,' 'Clayface' lead sleepy Halloween weekend
  2. clickondetroit.com › Box Office: 'You Can See Everything,' 'Clayface' lead sleepy Halloween weekend
  3. hollywoodoutbreak.com › Box Office Battle: Holmes Doc and 'Clayface' in Dead Heat
  4. yahoo.com › Buzzy Holmes doc wins slow Halloween box office in N. America
  5. mediaplaynews.com › A24's 'You Can See Everything' Ahead of Warner's 'Clayface' by a Nose at Slow Halloween Box Office Weekend

More on Film