22 States Sue to Block Trump Public Charge Green Card Rule
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- US News
- Immigration
New York and 21 other states, plus major cities, sued the Trump administration Monday to stop an expanded public charge rule taking effect Friday.
What happened: dual lawsuits filed in Manhattan
New York and 21 other states, along with the District of Columbia, sued the Trump administration Monday to block a new Department of Homeland Security rule that would give immigration officials wider discretion to deny green cards, visas or entry to applicants deemed likely to depend on government aid.
The rule is set to take effect Friday. Attorney General Letitia James announced the states' suit at a City Hall news conference, while New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani led a separate coalition of cities — Chicago, San Francisco, Seattle, Santa Clara County and King County — filing a parallel case.
Both suits were filed in the Southern District of New York and ask courts to declare the rule unlawful and bar DHS from using it.
Why the rule change is so expansive
The public charge provision dates to the Immigration Act of 1882, and for years officers counted only cash benefits such as TANF or Supplemental Security Income.
The first Trump administration widened that in 2020 to include Medicaid, food stamps and housing vouchers; the Biden administration reverted in 2022 to excluding non-cash benefits.
The new rule rescinds the Biden-era version and goes further than the 2020 one, specifying only that DHS 'will consider the receipt of any means tested public benefits,' without naming which programs.
It would also let officers weigh benefits applied for on behalf of family members, including US citizen children. The rule targets people with legal status; undocumented immigrants are not eligible for public benefits.
The chilling effect on families
Officials and advocates say fear is already driving eligible families away from benefits. Mamdani said New Yorkers not subject to the rule are already unenrolling from life-saving assistance.
Arline Cruz, director of health programs at Make the Road New York, told CNN her organization routinely hears from mixed-status families wondering whether to unenroll US citizen children from SNAP out of fear for immigration proceedings.
James framed the stakes in personal terms: 'Will getting health insurance hurt my chances of getting a green card? Will accepting food assistance when I fall on hard times be held against me?'
DHS said in a statement that 'sanctuary states are terrified they will lose federal funds' as people leave welfare programs.
The financial stakes for states
The plaintiff states argue they will bear billions in costs if immigrants, especially in mixed-status families, disenroll from safety net programs.
According to the lawsuit, DHS estimates states nationwide will lose about $4.05 billion in annual federal transfer payments for Medicaid and CHIP alone, with plaintiff states losing roughly $2.2 billion.
The states contend effects would ripple through public health, local economies, schools and public safety, and say New York is particularly exposed given its large immigrant population, universal school meals and reliance on federal Medicaid and SNAP funding.
About 588,000 applicants are subject to public charge reviews annually, according to DHS.
What comes next in court
The states argue DHS exceeded its authority because Congress never approved a broader interpretation of what it means to be a public charge, and that the rule is 'arbitrary and capricious' because the agency ignored harmful consequences and failed to justify the change.
Neither lawsuit had an assigned judge or scheduled hearing as of early Monday afternoon. Unless a court intervenes, DHS could begin applying the expanded standards Friday.
History offers the plaintiffs encouragement: similar litigation produced rulings against the first Trump administration's 2020 policy, which the Biden administration later abandoned before issuing its own 2022 rule.
Sources
- cnn.com › States sue to stop Trump rule that would make it harder for some immigrants to get green cards
- abc7chicago.com › Illinois, 21 other states sue to stop Trump rule on green cards
- economictimes.indiatimes.com › US states, cities and counties sue Trump administration over green card rule
- indiawest.com › 22 States Sue Trump Administration Over New Green Card Rule