SOCAN Sues Suno, Citing 150 AI Copies of Canadian Hits
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Entertainment
- Music Industry
- AI Copyright
- Suno
- Socan
SOCAN, Canada's largest music rights group, sued Suno, citing 150 AI-generated tracks it says copy Canadian songs without consent or payment.
What Happened
The Society of Composers, Authors and Music Publishers of Canada (SOCAN) filed a copyright infringement lawsuit against AI music platform Suno in Canada's Federal Court, as reported by CelebrityAccess and Music Ally.
The suit alleges Suno generated and streamed outputs that are identical or substantially similar to songs in SOCAN's repertoire, infringing performing rights without consent or compensation.
SOCAN's complaint identifies 150 publicly available Suno-generated tracks that allegedly replicate catalog works, which the organization describes as only 'the tip of the iceberg.' CEO Jennifer Brown told The Canadian Press: 'We want to make sure people get paid when their music is being used.'
Why It Is Surprising
The suit lands just days after singer-songwriter Jason Isbell and three other artists filed a proposed class action in the United States, and amid separate copyright suits from Universal Music Group, Sony Music Group and Round Hill Music.
What makes SOCAN's action distinct is that it is a national collecting society suing on behalf of an entire repertoire rather than individual artists, and it chose a forum where Suno's usual defense — that training on publicly available material is fair use — may not even apply.
Halifax entertainment lawyer Matthew Gorman told The Canadian Press that fair use is not part of Canadian copyright law, which instead has a narrower fair-dealing framework.
The Evidence
SOCAN has published a webpage showcasing AI-generated outputs alongside the songs they allegedly replicate, an approach Music Ally notes mirrors its German peer GEMA's strategy in its own litigation against Suno.
Examples include Avril Lavigne's 'Sk8er Boi,' Tom Cochrane's 'Life Is a Highway,' Nickelback's 'Photograph,' Joni Mitchell's 'Both Sides Now,' Céline Dion's 'A New Day Has Come' and The Tragically Hip's 'Bobcaygeon.'
The Canadian Press reports the Lavigne and Cochrane examples share the same melody, rhythm and chord progressions and much of the same lyrics, but with different voices — and, in Lavigne's case, some Korean words. SOCAN says all infringing outputs were available through ordinary use of the platform.
Suno's Position
Suno did not respond to interview requests from The Canadian Press by deadline, and the outlet reports Suno has argued in the US that training models on publicly available material qualifies as fair use.
The company's website, per that report, says it trains on 'publicly available music files and related metadata' from the open internet.
Responding to the separate US artists' suit, Music Ally reports Suno called the claims 'without merit,' saying the platform blocks prompts for specific artists' names or copyrighted songs and works with third-party providers to screen uploaded audio and lyrics.
Suno was valued at US$5.4 billion in its latest funding round and says it has more than two million paid subscribers.
The Stakes
SOCAN is seeking damages, a share of profits allegedly connected to the infringement, or statutory damages of up to CA$20,000 per infringed work, plus punitive damages and court orders requiring Suno to comply with copyright law, according to CelebrityAccess.
Brown framed the case as one of cultural sovereignty, telling The Canadian Press that 'large American tech companies' treat Canadian songs 'like it's big data to train their machine.'
She also said SOCAN pursued licensing talks with Suno since Day 1 but could not make meaningful progress, and welcomed Germany's recent GEMA court ruling against Suno as proof copyright law still applies to new technologies.
What Comes Next
Court documents cited by The Canadian Press give a defendant 30 days to file a statement of defence, with an extra 10 days if it files an intention to respond, and Music Ally says it will report Suno's response when it comes.
SOCAN is separately working with tech company Musical AI on tools to identify the music underlying AI-generated outputs and build a compensation framework for rights holders, per The Canadian Press.
Meanwhile, Suno faces reputational strain closer to home: The Hollywood Reporter reports it pulled an ad featuring Mary J. Blige after learning the deal was made with someone who falsely claimed to represent her, and it continues deals with Warner Music Group and BMG even as litigation mounts.
Sources
- celebrityaccess.com › SOCAN Sues Suno Over Alleged Copyright Infringement
- musically.com › Canada's Socan files latest music-industry lawsuit against Suno
- lethbridgeherald.com › SOCAN sues Suno, alleges AI company copies Canadian music without paying creators
- hollywoodreporter.com › Suno Scraps Mary J. Blige Ad After Making It Seem Singer Endorsed the AI Music Platform