Google, Meta and TikTok Sue to Block California's Teen Feed Law
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Tech
- Platform Regulation
- Child Safety
- California
- Litigation
Google, Meta and TikTok sued to block California's AB 1709 limits on personalized feeds and autoplay for users under 16.
Three tech giants take California to federal court
Google, Meta and TikTok have each filed separate federal lawsuits seeking to block California's AB 1709, a child online safety law that prohibits covered platforms from offering personalised algorithmic feeds, autoplay, infinite scrolling and notifications to users under 16.
Governor Gavin Newsom signed the bill on 10 September 2026, and it is scheduled to take effect on 1 January 2027. Filings in San Jose, San Francisco and Los Angeles name California Attorney General Rob Bonta as the sole defendant, according to Latination.
The legislation, authored by Long Beach Assemblymember Josh Lowenthal, passed the California Legislature with unanimous bipartisan support, NBC Los Angeles reports.
All three companies are asking the courts to declare the challenged provisions invalid and to stop the state from enforcing them before the January commencement date.
Why the lawsuits upend the usual script
What makes this fight notable is that all three rivals — Google, Meta and TikTok — reached the same conclusion simultaneously, filing separate suits against a law that cleared the legislature without a single dissenting vote.
The companies argue the law goes beyond regulating harmful content and instead dictates how they may organise and present lawful speech.
TikTok says California is effectively requiring it to build a different version of TikTok for under-16s, while Meta says the restriction interferes with its editorial choices on Facebook, Instagram and Threads.
Assemblymember Lowenthal, quoted by NBC Los Angeles, called the suits 'straight out of the big tech playbook' and accused the companies of using litigation to delay implementation while generating billions in profit in the meantime — allegations the companies dispute.
The companies' core arguments and the state's rebuttal
The platforms lean on First Amendment and Section 230 claims, arguing that selecting, ranking, recommending and presenting third-party content are protected editorial functions that California cannot regulate.
Google says personalised recommendations help younger users find relevant, educational content and that the law goes further than the earlier SB 976 by applying even where a parent consents, per Digital Watch Observatory.
TikTok notes its teen accounts carry more than 50 preset safety settings and Family Pairing controls, according to NBC Los Angeles.
Lowenthal countered that 'certain public health issues trump parental controls,' comparing the rule to helmet and car-seat laws, and said the bill regulates design features rather than content.
Latination reports that the Electronic Privacy Information Center argues addictive design features fall outside protected speech, while the EFF cautions compliance could force invasive identity checks for all Californians.
What is at stake for platforms and minors
California has positioned itself at the forefront of US child online safety regulation, with a broader framework covering addictive feeds, age-verification signals, warning labels, privacy and AI companion safeguards, Digital Watch Observatory reports.
Because the platforms operate globally, the arguments and outcomes in California could shape how they respond to similar child-safety laws elsewhere, including Australia's under-16 restrictions already being challenged in that country's High Court.
Lowenthal told NBC Los Angeles the goal is stopping a 'multi-trillion dollar sector' from mining children's attention spans for profit, while he insists he does not want to ban children from social media entirely.
The measure also establishes an eSafety Commission to advise lawmakers on future child protections.
What happens next
The law is scheduled to take effect on 1 January 2027, but the suits could change when or whether its restrictions are enforced — the companies hope to secure interim relief before the January commencement date, Digital Watch Observatory notes.
Lowenthal said he is confident Attorney General Rob Bonta will defend the legislation; Latination reports the Department of Justice pledged to defend what it calls common-sense protections for minors online.
Federal rulings will set key precedents for youth digital regulation nationwide, shaping interface design and algorithmic curation policies, according to Latination, which also notes the platforms face thousands of youth mental-health suits from school districts across the country.