Swift's 'Patient Zero' Sets Records as Critics Shrug

Taylor Swift's new 'Patient Zero' broke two 2026 Spotify records, even as critics including Todd Rundgren dismissed 'The Encore' as mediocre.

@sharedot

Swift's 'Patient Zero' Sets Records as Critics Shrug

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Music
  • Taylor Swift
  • Spotify
  • The Encore

Taylor Swift's new 'Patient Zero' broke two 2026 Spotify records, even as critics including Todd Rundgren dismissed 'The Encore' as mediocre.

Four New Songs, Two Instant Records

On September 25, Taylor Swift released *The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore*, a deluxe edition of her 2025 album carrying four new tracks: "Cleveland!", "Pink Clouding", "Babylon" and "Patient Zero".

According to Paste Magazine and Deadline, citing Variety, "Patient Zero" immediately broke Spotify's record for the most-streamed song by a female artist in a single day in 2026, while Swift herself logged the most streams of any female artist in a day this year.

Per Deadline, the four new songs occupied the top four spots on Spotify's Top 50 – Global chart as of Friday morning.

The Numbers Behind the Surge

The raw totals show why the release dominated the platform: Deadline reports "Patient Zero" had been played 13,709,109 times since its Thursday release, with "Cleveland!" at 9,620,630, "Pink Clouding" at 8,785,117 and "Babylon" at 8,419,108.

Swift told fans on Instagram that the songs were written in Sweden with Max Martin and Shellback after she took a trip to celebrate *The Life of a Showgirl*'s biggest first week for an album in history — "there was a studio there, and we did what we do when we feel anything at all: We wrote more songs," she wrote.

Rundgren Calls Her 'Apotheosis of Mediocrity'

The streaming triumph landed alongside a strikingly hostile review from an unexpected corner.

NME reports that veteran producer Todd Rundgren — whose credits include Meat Loaf's *Bat Out Of Hell*, the New York Dolls' debut and XTC's *Skylarking* — told Vulture that if he made a 2026 parody album, his target would be "Taylor Swift, of course. There's an argument to be made that she ruined music."

He called her "the apotheosis of mediocrity" and said "She's not a great singer. She's not a great songwriter. She's not a great dancer." NME notes he did single out Lady Gaga as a "real musician."

A 1/5 From the Student Press

Rundgren is not the only dissenter. North Texas Daily's reviewer Thomas Treviño gave *The Encore* a 1/5, writing that the four songs "are hollow and play as though someone prompted an AI chatbot to 'make four Taylor Swift songs.'"

NME separately notes that the original *Showgirl* drew a mixed critical response, with NME's own review earning three stars. Swift has said she is untroubled by such takes: "I have a lot of respect for people's subjective opinions on art — I'm not the art police," per NME.

Lyric Theories and a Cleveland Declaration

Fan interpretation is doing its own promotional work.

According to Yahoo Lifestyle Canada, "Cleveland!" — named for Travis Kelce's home city — declares him "the love of my life" after their July marriage, while "Pink Clouding" expresses regret toward a former partner and "Babylon" laments "missing all the best parts" of a past relationship.

Yahoo adds that fans read "Patient Zero" as possibly referencing the support Swift offered Sophie Turner after her 2023 split from Joe Jonas. North Texas Daily reports "Patient Zero" even prompted fans to theorize an entire new album was coming.

What Comes Next: The VMAs

The full "Patient Zero" video — directed by Swift and starring Dakota Johnson and Colin Farrell — premieres at the MTV VMAs this Sunday, September 27, per Deadline and Paste.

The same weekend, Swift will receive the VMAs' first-ever Artist Director Honors, created for "artists who have pushed creative boundaries and developed a clear directorial voice," Paste reports, and she is nominated for nine more awards including Artist of the Year and Video of the Year.

Deadline notes Swiftophiles are also deciphering cryptic words from her Emmy telecast skit — "Saccharide. Aries. From the vineyard. North or south" — in case Sunday brings a bigger reveal.

Sources

  1. pastemagazine.com › Taylor Swift breaks two Spotify records with "Patient Zero" release
  2. deadline.com › Taylor Swift Breaks Spotify Records With "Patient Zero"
  3. nme.com › Todd Rundgren claims that Taylor Swift "ruined music" and calls her the "apotheosis of mediocrity"
  4. ntdaily.com › 'The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore' fails to bring Taylor Swift back to the spotlight
  5. ca.style.yahoo.com › Taylor Swift breaks two Spotify records

More on Music