Patagonia Sues Trump Again Over Utah Monument Cuts

Patagonia, tribal, and environmental groups sued Trump over his 90% cuts to Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments.

@sharedot

Patagonia Sues Trump Again Over Utah Monument Cuts

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • US News
  • Patagonia
  • Bears Ears
  • National Monuments
  • Utah

Patagonia, tribal, and environmental groups sued Trump over his 90% cuts to Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments.

What happened

On Wednesday, September 2, outdoor apparel company Patagonia announced it had joined a coalition of tribal and environmental groups suing the Trump administration over its July proclamations that shrank Bears Ears National Monument by roughly 90% and Grand Staircase-Escalante by about 90%, stripping protections from nearly 3 million acres of Utah public land.

Three complaints were filed in U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., seeking to reactivate litigation first brought in 2017 during Trump's first term.

That earlier case was administratively closed without a final judgment after President Biden restored the monuments in 2021, and the new filings challenge both the 2017 and 2026 proclamations. Patagonia CEO Ryan Gellert called the orders illegal and said they "betray Tribal sovereignty."

Why it is surprising

Patagonia is a private company suing a sitting president over public lands for a second time — in 2017 it became the first company ever to do so, according to UPI.

The move reunites an unusual coalition: a major retailer, tribal nations including the Navajo Nation, Hopi Tribe, Ute Mountain Ute Tribe, Zuni Tribe and Ute Indian Tribe, and ten environmental groups such as the NRDC, Sierra Club and Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance.

The evidence and legal argument

The lawsuits rest on a simple claim about the Antiquities Act of 1906: it gives presidents power to designate national monuments but not to abolish them "in whole or in part."

Gellert and NRDC executive director Christy Goldfuss both made that argument, with Goldfuss saying Congress never gave presidents the power to tear monuments down.

According to The Daily Caller, a Congressional Research Service report from July noted the act is silent on a president's authority to diminish or eliminate monuments, and scholars are split — some argue only Congress holds that power, while others cite historical precedent.

The Trump administration counters that the act "has been stretched" and points to a Department of Justice memo from May 2025 providing the legal framework for the reductions. UPI reports Utah's Republican governor, Spencer Cox, argues the monuments violated the act's smallest-area principle.

The stakes

Nearly 3 million acres lost monument protections, opening the way to oil and gas development and uranium mining.

According to Yahoo News/The Independent, the Center for Western Priorities said the lands could be sold or leased to oil, gas, mining or logging companies within 60 days, and at least nine mining claims have already been filed on formerly protected lands.

The monuments hold ancient cliff dwellings, pueblo homes, rock art and sites sacred to tribes, plus dinosaur fossils found nowhere else on Earth. Goldfuss warned: "Once you open these lands to mining and drilling, what gets lost is not coming back."

The White House argues the move restores public access and "multiple-use activities" such as grazing, hunting and motorized recreation, though UPI reports Utah wildlife officials say those activities were already permitted within the monuments.

Public opinion and coalition

Patagonia argues the rollback runs against broad public support for land conservation. The Daily Caller reports a 2025 YouGov poll sponsored by the Trust for Public Land found 85% of Democratic voters and 61% of Republican voters oppose selling public lands.

Gellert said hunters, fishers, hikers, climbers and voters of all political stripes support public lands, calling the decision contrary to what people want.

What comes next

The three complaints will now move through federal court in Washington, D.C., seeking to revive the dormant 2017 cases and block both the 2017 and 2026 proclamations.

Steve Bloch, legal director of the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance, said the filings intend to make sure "Trump doesn't have the final word over the fate of these treasured landscapes."

A core question for the courts is whether a president can shrink a monument a prior president designated — a power Congress has never clearly granted.

Gellert framed the fight as part of a broader pattern, saying the administration has waged an aggressive campaign against air, water and land protections that "will take years if not decades to undo."

Patagonia, which helped establish Bears Ears alongside the Bears Ears Inter-Tribal Coalition in 2016, says it is committed to defending the monument into the future.

Sources

  1. theguardian.com › Patagonia sues Trump over slashing of protected areas in Utah
  2. moabtimes.com › Trump's move to slash Utah national monuments sparks lawsuits from Patagonia and environmental groups
  3. upi.com › Patagonia sues Trump administration over Bears Ears National Monument
  4. dailycaller.com › Outdoor Retail Giant Sues Trump For Shrinking Two National Monuments
  5. uk.news.yahoo.com › Outdoor gear retailer Patagonia sues Trump for shrinking beloved Utah national monument managed by tribes

More on US News