Coroner Disputes Measles Label in Newborn's Death
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Lifestyle
- Measles Outbreak
- Public Health
- Vaccines
Pennsylvania's first measles-associated deaths spark a political firestorm as the county coroner.
Two Deaths Announced
On August 25, Pennsylvania officials announced two measles-associated deaths among unvaccinated Lancaster County residents — the first such deaths in the state in 35 years and the first in the United States this year.
Governor Josh Shapiro and Health Secretary Dr. Debra Bogen urged vaccination at a press conference at Women & Babies Hospital. The state initially withheld details about the deceased, citing privacy, but later confirmed one was a newborn.
According to CNN, Shapiro used the moment to blame federal officials, including HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., for sowing vaccine misinformation that has driven down immunization rates.
Coroner's Contradiction
Lancaster County Coroner Dr. Stephen Diamantoni publicly disputed the state's framing. According to NBC News, Diamantoni said the newborn died shortly after birth from an internal hemorrhage and traumatic rupture of the spleen, not from measles.
He reported finding evidence of the measles virus in the infant's lung tissue but said the forensic pathologist who performed the autopsy did not consider the death measles-related.
LancasterOnline reports that Diamantoni found no swelling or enlargement of the spleen, which would have been the mechanism by which measles could have contributed to a rupture. His investigation into the cause of the laceration remains ongoing.
Experts Weigh In
Infectious disease experts say both interpretations could coexist. CIDRAP reports that Dr. Amesh Adalja of Johns Hopkins explained that measles can enlarge the spleen, making it fragile and vulnerable to laceration during delivery, though the academic literature on this is sparse.
Dr. Paul Offit of Children's Hospital of Philadelphia told the Philadelphia Inquirer that if the spleen was not enlarged due to measles, the coroner should provide an alternative explanation for the rupture.
According to NBC News, Offit said that through conversations with state health officials he learned that these patients would not have died were it not for measles. Medical Daily notes that detecting whether a spleen was enlarged after it has already ruptured is inherently difficult.
Political Eruption
The dispute quickly escalated into a political confrontation. According to CIDRAP, Kennedy posted on X that the deaths were fabricated and accused Shapiro of fearmongering and weaponizing infectious disease fears for political gain.
The CDC posted on X that it was working to determine what actually occurred and raised questions about whether the governor's office had shared information with the agency.
LancasterOnline reports that Lancaster County Commissioner Josh Parsons, a Republican, publicly questioned whether the patients died of or with measles and cited Kennedy's remarks.
According to CNN, Shapiro told reporters that Kennedy's misinformation has real-life consequences, referencing Kennedy's 2021 visit to Lancaster where he suggested measles could be treated with chicken soup and vitamin A.
The Outbreak's Scale
Pennsylvania has confirmed 424 measles cases this year, with 94 diagnosed in the past week alone and 73 hospitalizations, according to NBC News. Lancaster County accounts for 197 cases, making it the epicenter of the nation's largest current outbreak.
Medical Daily reports that MMR coverage among Lancaster County children fell from 95.5 percent in 2017 to 87.6 percent last year, dropping below the 95 percent threshold needed for herd immunity.
CNN notes that the United States has recorded more than 2,700 cases nationally this year, the highest annual total since 1991, and experts expect the country may soon lose its measles elimination status.
What Comes Next
LancasterOnline reports that Diamantoni's investigation into the newborn's death is ongoing and that foul play is not suspected. He confirmed the child died at a birthing center in Christiana Borough on August 14 and that the mother is alive.
According to CIDRAP, Adalja warned that with the school year starting, large numbers of unvaccinated children will be gathering, creating further exposure risk.
The state has broadened its early MMR vaccination guidance to include 30 counties with detected measles transmission, according to LancasterOnline. No information about the second measles-associated death has been released, and the underlying records for both cases remain unreleased.
Sources
- cidrap.umn.edu › Newborn one of 2 measles-associated deaths in Pennsylvania
- cnn.com › One of two measles-related deaths of unvaccinated people in Pennsylvania was an infant
- staradvertiser.com › Infant dies in Pennsylvania measles outbreak as RFK Jr. questions cause
- nbcnews.com › Coroner says baby with measles in Pennsylvania died of a ruptured spleen
- lancasteronline.com › Lancaster County coroner shares details, says measles didn't contribute to newborn's death
- medicaldaily.com › A Newborn Was Among Pennsylvania's Two Measles Associated Deaths, and the County Coroner Disputes the Label