Supreme Court Opens Term With Boulder Climate Suit
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Climate
- Climate Policy
- Supreme Court
- Climate Litigation
The Supreme Court begins its new term Monday hearing a bid by Exxon and Suncor to block Boulder's billion-dollar climate damages lawsuit.
What happened: justices take up the Boulder case
When the Supreme Court returns to the bench Monday for the first time since late June, it will kick off its new term with a major climate change case, according to CBS News.
The justices will hear an appeal from energy companies Suncor Energy and Exxon Mobil trying to block dozens of lawsuits by states and local governments seeking money damages for past and future harms they allege are caused by the buildup of greenhouse gases.
The issue before the court is whether Boulder's state-court suit can proceed or is barred by federal law. Billions of dollars are potentially at stake, and a decision is expected by summer 2027.
Why it is surprising: the term opens on climate
It is unusual for the court to open a term with a climate liability fight rather than defer it to the docket's back end, and the Associated Press reports the case sits high on the agenda alongside religious rights and President Trump's immigration crackdown.
Boulder's 2018 lawsuit alleges Exxon and Suncor's production and allegedly deceptive marketing of fossil fuels drove unchecked use that rapidly raised greenhouse gas concentrations, forcing the city to confront extreme heat, larger and more frequent wildfires and ecosystem damage.
The Colorado Supreme Court already sided with Boulder, sending the fight to Washington.
The evidence and the recusal wrinkle
Only eight of the nine justices will participate, CBS News reports: Justice Samuel Alito recused himself without giving a reason, and his 2025 financial disclosure shows individual holdings in ConocoPhillips and Phillips 66, though he reported no individual stock in Exxon or Suncor.
His absence leaves open the possibility of a 4-4 split, which would let the Colorado Supreme Court's decision allowing the suit stand.
Boulder's lawyers argue that climate change being a global problem does not disempower states from redressing its local harms, and that the suit targets deceptive marketing and production rather than emissions themselves.
The stakes for the industry
Boulder's suit is one of dozens filed by states and local governments against energy companies in state courts seeking damages for climate harms, so the outcome could shape whether that wider wave of litigation can proceed.
Exxon and Suncor argue in filings that the Constitution and the Clean Air Act preclude claims over interstate greenhouse-gas emissions, warning that upholding the Colorado ruling would authorize all fifty states and tens of thousands of municipalities to set conflicting climate policies through local courts.
The Trump administration backs the companies, arguing the litigation is a power grab intended to impose regulations on emissions, per the Associated Press.
The states' counterargument
West Virginia and 25 other states are backing Suncor and Exxon, and West Virginia Solicitor General Michael Williams told reporters that a national problem requires a national solution, saying states cannot make emitters pay worldwide for emissions anywhere.
Boulder counters that litigation over local impacts of global problems is routine, pointing to food contamination, human trafficking and the fentanyl crisis, and says its claims do not seek emissions regulation.
William & Mary law professor Jonathan Adler, who filed a friend-of-the-court brief supporting Boulder, told CBS News the case is a judgment about whether folks get to make their case, not whether the suits will ultimately succeed.
What comes next
Arguments Monday open a term in which the Associated Press says climate change, immigration and gun rights are high on the agenda, with assault-weapons cases set for December arguments.
For the Boulder case, CBS News reports a decision is expected by summer 2027, and even a win for the city would only let its claims proceed in state court, where the scope of what it can pursue could be narrowed significantly.
The dispute remains in its early stages, meaning the billion-dollar question of who pays for climate damages stays unresolved long after this week's argument.
Sources
- cbsnews.com › Supreme Court to weigh energy companies' bid to end Boulder climate-change lawsuit
- audacy.com › A new Supreme Court term begins with cases on climate change, immigration and gun rights
- bozemandailychronicle.com › A new Supreme Court term begins with cases on climate change, immigration and gun rights