Study: About 3 in 4 Deceased Former NFL Players Had CTE
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Health
- Cte
- NFL
- Brain Health
A JAMA study found 74.5% of former NFL players who died from 2008 to 2023 had CTE, even after adjusting for brain donation bias.
What the new study found
A study published Wednesday in JAMA Network Open estimates that 74.5% of former NFL players who died between 2008 and 2023 had chronic traumatic encephalopathy, the degenerative brain disease linked to repeated head impacts.
Researchers from Boston University, Mass General Brigham and the Concussion & CTE Foundation examined 2,362 deceased former players, 396 of whom had donated their brains. Among 387 donors whose CTE status was determined, 362 — 93.5% — showed CTE neuropathology.
The study also estimated that 27.2% of the deceased players had dementia during their lifetime, a figure researchers said likely underestimates its prevalence.
Lead author Julia Gallini called the nearly 75% estimated prevalence "concerning," saying more effort is needed to support families, diagnose CTE during life, and treat CTE-related symptoms.
Why the estimate is surprising
The finding is a dramatic refinement of a study published in August in The BMJ, which could only say that somewhere between roughly 25% and 98% of former NFL players who died between 2016 and 2021 had CTE.
Yorghos Tripodis, a Boston University professor of biostatistics and author of the new paper, told ABC News that the earlier range was too broad and that the group wanted a more precise answer.
Even he was startled by the result: according to the Spotlight on America report by WCIV, Tripodis said the number was "astounding" and that his team went back, double-checked and rewrote the code independently to make sure it was right.
Correcting for donation bias
Most CTE research has relied on voluntarily donated brains, raising concerns that estimates are inflated because families who noticed cognitive or behavioral symptoms are more likely to donate a loved one's brain.
To address this, researchers estimated that families who observed cognitive symptoms were about five times more likely to donate a brain, then adjusted their analysis accordingly.
They used brain bank data, National Death Index records, dementia and mild cognitive impairment data from the 2022 NFL-Long study, and player characteristics such as years and positions played.
Even under very conservative assumptions, Tripodis told ABC News the estimate does not go below 60% — Medscape reports the conservative lower-bound analysis put prevalence at 63.7%.
How experts weigh the caveats
Experts cautioned that the findings apply only to deceased former players and cannot be applied to living athletes or to youth and college football.
Dr. Kristen Dams-O'Connor, director of the Brain Injury Research Center at Mount Sinai, told CBS News the results "cannot and should not be interpreted as being representative of current living athletes," noting many studied players ended their careers long ago, before recent rule changes and equipment like Guardian Caps.
She also flagged gaps such as accounting for roughly 20,000 NFL players who could have died in the 15-year window but did not. CBS News' Dr. Jon LaPook noted the figure may be an overestimate because it counts signs of CTE in the brain, not actual symptoms.
Dr. Rachel Grashow of Harvard, who was not involved, told CNN it is important to separate CTE from dementia, since cognitive symptoms appear mainly in stages III and IV.
The stakes for football and beyond
More than 20 million men alive today in the US have played football, so understanding CTE rates is a significant public health question, as Tripodis told ABC News.
The NFL said in a statement that it "continuously strives to make the game of football safer, including by implementing strategies to reduce concussions and head impacts," while the NFL Players Association said such studies are "critical to improving our understanding of football's long-term impacts" and reiterated its commitment to supporting players during and after their careers.
Medscape reports that Chris Nowinski, CEO of the Concussion & CTE Foundation, hopes the 75% estimate will shift the conversation beyond donation-bias debates and spur support for former players with suspected CTE.
He noted that brain banks worldwide are finding CTE in the majority of professional football, soccer, ice hockey and rugby players studied, though smaller samples make selection bias harder to quantify.
What comes next
Researchers say the field needs a reliable biomarker to diagnose CTE during life, which would let them follow people over time and learn why some with CTE pathology develop symptoms while others do not.
Dr. Jay Alberts, director of the Cleveland Clinic Concussion Center, told CBS News that CTE may have measurable early warning signs, and that tracking "instrumental activities of daily living" like driving or balancing a checkbook — skills that change five to seven years before diagnosis in Alzheimer's and Parkinson's — could help detect changes earlier.
Dr. Jeremy Tanner of UT San Antonio told CBS News that such long-term research could benefit other neurodegenerative diseases too.
Meanwhile, Tripodis advised Medscape that cognitive or mood changes in former players should be evaluated clinically for potentially treatable causes such as depression, sleep disorders and substance use rather than automatically attributed to CTE.
Nowinski added that comparable estimates are needed for youth, high school and college players.
Sources
- espn.com › Study: Estimated 75% of NFL players who died from 2008 to 2023 had CTE
- abcnews.com › New study estimates about 3 in 4 former NFL players had CTE
- medscape.com › Nearly 3 in 4 Former NFL Players Likely Had CTE at Death
- abcnews4.com › Nearly 75% of deceased former NFL players had CTE, new study estimates
- cbsnews.com › Experts weigh in on study estimating 75% of NFL players who died in recent years had signs of CTE
- cnn.com › New study suggests 3 in 4 former NFL players who died from 2008 to 2023 had CTE | CNN