Palantir and Apple Beat Estimates — and Both Stocks Fell Anyway
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Stock Market
- Palantir
- Apple
- Earnings
Palantir and Apple both topped earnings estimates yet dropped roughly 3% as investors fixated on slowing bookings and squeezed margins.
What Happened: Beats Across the Board, Sell-Offs at the Open
Palantir reported third-quarter revenue that nearly doubled year over year and blew past $2 billion for the first time, while Apple delivered fiscal fourth-quarter revenue of $114.5 billion, up 12% annually, with EPS of $2.10 — both above Wall Street expectations. Yet neither stock celebrated.
Palantir fell about 3% and Apple dropped more than 2% in Tuesday trading, leaving investors to parse why strong prints produced weak reactions.
Why It's Surprising: A 153% Bookings Boom Turns Into 11%
The shock sits inside Palantir's bookings data. CNBC reports that U.S. commercial total contract value closed at $1.5 billion in Q3, up just 11% from last year — a dramatic reversal from Q2's record $2.1 billion, which had grown 153%.
U.S. commercial revenue also topped government revenue for the first time, but analysts seized on the slowdown in what they call "forward indicators" rather than the headline revenue beat.
The Evidence: Analysts Weigh Fluke Versus Structure
CNBC cites a Piper Sandler note saying investors will "no doubt be looking for evidence in subsequent quarters that 11% growth in U.S. commercial TCV bookings is a fluke of duration and not something structural," adding that demand still outstrips supply.
Goldman Sachs analysts attributed part of the slowdown to shorter contract durations, writing that "the key will be converting shorter duration contracts into longer duration commitments." Palantir also raised its full-year revenue forecast to roughly $8.53 billion, per investingLive.
The Stakes: Apple's Memory Crunch and a 25% Premium
Apple's own decline traces to profitability, not sales. The company guided December-quarter gross margins to 45%–46%, down from 47.9%, and CNBC reports memory costs rose this quarter as a global component shortage bites, expected to limit Mac and iPad supply.
Violeta Todorova of Leverage Shares told CNBC that "the concern is profitability," and warned Apple's 25% gain in 2026 leaves "little room for disappointment."
What Comes Next: Watching Whether the Declines Hold
Both moves stayed within options-implied ranges — Apple's expected move was ±4.25% and Palantir's ±13.32% per investingLive — meaning neither was an unusually severe shock, despite an Earnings Mood Score of 4/10 described as cautious and slightly worsening. investingLive flags a useful near-term test: whether Apple and Palantir recover their initial losses during the November 3 regular session.
Piper Sandler's framing sets the bar — next quarter must show whether bookings growth was a fluke.