Kelly Clarkson's Brooklyn Shop Feud Gets a Quoting-Back Rebuttal

Kelly Clarkson's viral callout of Brooklyn's Art of Play prompted the store to claim she tried to buy a bird automaton never for sale.

@sharedot

Kelly Clarkson's Brooklyn Shop Feud Gets a Quoting-Back Rebuttal

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Celebrity
  • Kelly Clarkson
  • Feuds
  • Viral

Kelly Clarkson's viral callout of Brooklyn's Art of Play prompted the store to claim she tried to buy a bird automaton never for sale.

What Happened

Kelly Clarkson posted on X on Saturday to her 8.8 million followers that she drove to Brooklyn's Art of Play, a shop selling magical home goods, puzzles, games, toys and books, expecting to buy several items.

She claimed an employee looked at her as if she could not afford the goods and offered something comparable instead, telling him "you're an idiot and just lost a huge sale." She closed by saying the store treats shoppers like Julia Roberts's character in Pretty Woman, adding a thumbs-down emoji.

The Store's Reversal

The store says Clarkson inquired about buying "Molly," a one-of-a-kind singing and dancing bird automaton that anchors the magic shows the shop hosts, and that Molly is permanently attached to the wall and was never for sale.

The shop wrote that everyone who walks in is invited to "pick things up and play," and expressed shock that a "small local business was suddenly attacked by 8 million people who have never visited our store."

Why It's Surprising

The reversal is the remarkable part: rather than apologizing, the shop ended its statement by quoting Clarkson's own 2011 hit back at her, writing "as a talented popular singer once said 'what doesn't kill you makes you stronger,'" and saying it hopes to clear things up with Kelly someday.

TMZ notes the business also shared positive customer testimonials praising staff kindness, including one reading "for what it's worth i think @artofplay is a great store!" Page Six reports the shop had earlier posted, then deleted, those reviews about the staff's "kindness."

The Fallout and Evidence

Clarkson's initial post drew heavy coverage from outlets including Fox News, US Weekly and USA Today, per Mediaite.

Mediaite also reports the shop was blitzed with bad reviews and comments online, with one Google reviewer jokingly writing "walked in and the worker told me that the homeless shelter was a few blocks down," and that Art of Play turned off comments on all of its Instagram posts.

Mediaite adds that Fox News host Greg Gutfeld slammed Clarkson for peddling a "story of victimhood" when her money and status couldn't persuade the store to sell an unavailable item.

What Comes Next

For now, the standoff remains unresolved, with Clarkson's version of events still circulating online while Art of Play says it will "keep our heads down" and hopes to clear things up with the singer someday, as TMZ puts it, wanting to "Breakaway" from her narrative.

The episode shows the stakes of a single celebrity post: a small Brooklyn shop suddenly fielding national outrage, review bombing and millions of opinions from people who have never visited, all over an automaton that was never on the market in the first place.

Sources

  1. yahoo.com › Kelly Clarkson's Viral Feud With Brooklyn Magic Shop Escalates
  2. pagesix.com › Brooklyn store outed by Kelly Clarkson responds
  3. tmz.com › Kelly Clarkson Store Feud: Brooklyn Shop Fires Back

More on Celebrity