Texas Roadhouse Confirms Steak Mix-Up After Viral Claim

Texas Roadhouse confirmed one sirloin-for-filet mix-up at its Forsyth, Illinois location after a customer's viral video accused it of a repeat swap.

@sharedot

Texas Roadhouse Confirms Steak Mix-Up After Viral Claim

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • AI
  • Dining
  • Consumer Vigilance
  • Viral Video

Texas Roadhouse confirmed one sirloin-for-filet mix-up at its Forsyth, Illinois location after a customer's viral video accused it of a repeat swap.

What Happened at the Forsyth Steakhouse

Illinois resident Kenneth Card, a weekly customer at a Texas Roadhouse in Forsyth for over a year, posted a TikTok in early October claiming the restaurant served him an 8-ounce sirloin — worth about $20 — instead of the roughly $30 filet mignon he ordered.

According to Fox News, he says it happened on three separate visits, and his warning video drew more than 30,000 views. Card told Fox News Digital his background in hotel and restaurant kitchens, preparing and cutting steaks, gave him the confidence to identify the cut on sight.

Why the Claim Struck a Nerve

The price gap at stake is roughly $10 per plate: Fox News reports the Forsyth location's website lists the 8-ounce sirloin at about $20 and the filet mignon at about $30. Filet mignon is among the highest-priced items on the chain's menu, so a swap means paying a premium for a cheaper cut.

Commenters split between blaming one location and admitting they could not tell the cuts apart — Card described a filet as melting in the mouth while sirloin is 'a little grittier, a little chewier,' a texture difference he says trained eyes and palates catch but casual diners may miss.

The Viral Video Evidence

Card's video showed the meat on his plate as he explained why he believed it was not a true filet, per afromag.com.ng.

On his third incident, he said, he asked a manager for a review; the restaurant took the steak away for a second opinion, staff told him it was not what he ordered, and he left with a replacement — to go — before posting the clip after getting home.

Fox News reports he said the third visit followed one where he raised the issue and received a filet, and another where he ate the steak without complaining.

Corporate Response and Disputed Numbers

Texas Roadhouse reviewed the complaints and confirmed at least one mix-up at the Forsyth restaurant, telling Fox News Digital that management 'quickly made it right' by replacing the steak.

A spokesperson said the company has 'not been able to track that this occurred on three occasions,' and that team members double-check food for quality and accuracy as it leaves the kitchen.

The chain advises any guest who believes they received the wrong steak or an incorrect charge to alert their server immediately so the restaurant team can address it.

Stakes and What Comes Next

The episode shows how quickly a single diner's complaint can force a national chain into a public accounting, as afromag.com.ng notes it has pushed many diners to inspect their plates more closely at popular steakhouses.

Former restaurant workers commenting on the video said mistakes can happen on a busy grill line, but customers paying premium prices expect the cut they ordered.

Card, for his part, said he is done with the Forsyth location — 'I'll try somewhere else' — though he said he was surprised by the attention and simply wanted people to get what they pay for.

Sources

  1. foxnews.com › Man says Texas Roadhouse served him $20 steak instead of pricier filet multiple times
  2. afromag.com.ng › Texas Roadhouse Steak Complaint: Kenneth Card Claims Sirloin Swapped for Filet
  3. latination.com › Texas Roadhouse customer spots a $10 steak difference that other diners might miss

More on AI