Critics Split: 'Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story' on Netflix

Ryan Murphy's fourth 'Monster' installment gives the anthology its first female killer, and critics are split between calling it engaging and bonkers.

@sharedot

Critics Split: 'Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story' on Netflix

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Streaming
  • Netflix
  • Lizzie Borden
  • True Crime
  • Ryan Murphy

Ryan Murphy's fourth 'Monster' installment gives the anthology its first female killer, and critics are split between calling it engaging and bonkers.

What happened: Netflix's 'Monster' goes Victorian

Netflix premiered "Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story" on September 17, the fourth installment of Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan's true-crime anthology and, as Variety and TV Insider both note, the first to center a female killer.

Ella Beatty, daughter of Warren Beatty and Annette Bening, stars as Lizzie Borden, accused of axing her father Andrew (Charlie Hunnam) and stepmother Abby (Rebecca Hall) in Fall River, Massachusetts in 1892.

Vicky Krieps plays housemaid Bridget Sullivan, with Sarah Paulson appearing as Aileen Wuornos.

Why it's surprising: a genuine critical split

The divide among reviewers is unusually sharp for the franchise. Variety says the season "finally delivers an outrageously engaging" installment, calling Beatty's performance engaging and praising the show's "playful, vibrant tone" and its framing of the oppressive conditions women faced.

The Guardian takes the opposite view, describing the series as a "blood-soaked, borderline-fetishistic fever dream" that feels like it was written by adolescent boys, fixated on Lizzie's periods and packed with beheadings.

TV Insider, meanwhile, simply bills it as a "lurid" psychosexual exploration of female rage.

The evidence: what the show invents versus what's known

Both the Variety and Guardian reviews describe the series' inventions: a friendship between Lizzie and Bridget that becomes a romantic plot, and Bridget reading Lizzie the tale of Countess Elizabeth Báthory, also played by Krieps.

According to USA Today, the real case shows Andrew Borden was struck 11 times and Abby 19 times on August 4, 1892, and the Borden-Bridget affair theory has surfaced in earlier works but has no confirming evidence.

Variety concedes the narrative "bends and twists the truth" of what occurred in the Borden home.

The stakes: history's acquittal haunts the retelling

USA Today reports that an all-male jury acquitted Lizzie Borden on June 20, 1893 after deliberating on a lack of evidence — women couldn't serve on Massachusetts juries until 1950 — and that she lived as a shunned recluse until her 1927 death.

CBS News, which spent a night in the restored Borden house for a "48 Hours" investigation, argues jurors in 1893 simply found it hard to believe an affluent woman could commit such violence, a framing that echoes The Guardian's complaint that the show ignores the prejudices that likely shaped the verdict.

Why the anthology format draws fire

Both reviews flag the series' habit of weaving in other killers. Variety reports that Sarah Paulson's Aileen Wuornos — whose killings came nearly a century after Borden's — appears in the trailer, and recalls the previous "Ed Gein Story" inserting Ted Bundy and Richard Speck via a fabricated plot.

Variety finds the Báthory thread, by contrast, woven seamlessly into the show's gothic campiness. The Guardian sees the same pattern as further evidence the writers were improvising without a thesis.

What comes next: an eight-hour binge is live

The eight-episode season is now streaming on Netflix, having screened for critics only two episodes ahead of the premiere, according to Variety's review — meaning verdicts on the back half remain to come.

Variety says the show's closing message is that "the last person anyone should underestimate is a woman," while The Guardian argues the hours ahead should have gotten down to "real work" on Borden's era.

Fans deciding for themselves now have all eight episodes, and the true-crime conversation around Fall River is already refreshed by CBS's return to the murder house.

Sources

  1. variety.com › Netflix's 'Monster' Finally Delivers an Outrageously Engaging Season With 'The Lizzie Borden Story': TV Review
  2. tvinsider.com › New Blood for 'Traitors,' Monstrous Lizzie Borden, 'Adults' Finale, a Fairy Tale 'Trek'
  3. theguardian.com › Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story review – it's like Ryan Murphy's new series was written by adolescent boys
  4. usatoday.com › The real Lizzie Borden story – What Netflix's 'Monster' got right about the murders
  5. cbsnews.com › I slept in the room where Lizzie Borden's stepmother was murdered. Here's what I discovered.

More on Streaming