Supreme Court Leans Toward Cutoff for Late Mail Ballots
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- US News
- Supreme Court
- Voting Rights
- Elections
The Supreme Court's conservative majority may limit counting of mail ballots arriving after Election Day in an RNC challenge to Mississippi.
Justices grill Mississippi's five-day grace period
The Supreme Court's conservative majority on Monday appeared sympathetic to the Republican National Committee's bid to limit the counting of mail-in ballots that arrive after Election Day, even if they were postmarked on or before that day, per ABC News.
The case targets a Mississippi law allowing absentee ballots to arrive as late as five days after polls close.
Justice Neil Gorsuch observed that both sides agree there must be a final decision by the voter and receipt by somebody by Election Day, and Justice Brett Kavanaugh said a first reading of the text suggests in-person voting on that day.
Thirty states plus D.C. have similar grace periods, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures, as cited in the report.
Why the arguments cut against decades of practice
The dispute turns on the meaning of the single word "election" in federal law. Republicans argue the term covers both ballot submission and receipt by election officials; Mississippi and voter advocacy groups say it means when voters mark and submit their ballots.
ABC News reports Justice Samuel Alito complained that "we don't have Election Day anymore. We have election month or we have election months," while Justice Amy Coney Barrett probed whether states could even let voters recall mailed ballots.
Hundreds of thousands of late-arriving ballots were legally counted across 22 states and territories in the 2024 election, according to the U.S. Election Assistance Commission via ABC News, yet the RNC offered no showing of actual fraud from post-Election Day receipt itself.
Liberals warn a ruling could reach early voting too
The court's three liberal justices pushed back on the challenge, with ABC News reporting that Justice Sonia Sotomayor said the Constitution vests election rules in states unless Congress supersedes them, and Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson noted Congress has never overridden the long-standing practice.
Justice Elena Kagan pressed RNC attorney Paul Clement on whether the same logic would implicate early voting, asking where the argument would end.
A Pew Research Center survey cited in the report found 58% of Americans support allowing any voter to cast a ballot by mail, though support splits sharply by party — 83% of Democratic-leaning voters favor it versus 68% of Republican-leaning voters opposed.
A busy term for a court weighing border claims too
A decision on mail ballots is expected by the end of June, per ABC News, and would land amid broader litigation over President Trump's second-term border policies.
ABC7 reports the court on Tuesday heard a separate challenge over whether migrants must be allowed to apply for asylum at ports of entry, with the administration arguing a person stopped in Mexico has not "arrived in" the United States and immigrant advocates calling the right to seek asylum a legal and moral one.
Voting-rights advocates warn an abrupt change to mail rules could cause rejection of ballots delayed in delivery, while Republicans say there is ample time to educate voters ahead of November.