Ninth Circuit Unanimously Blocks California's ICE ID Law
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- US News
- Immigration
- Courts
- California
A unanimous Ninth Circuit panel blocked California's No Vigilantes Act ID requirement for federal agents, ruling it violates the Supremacy Clause.
What happened: appeals court halts agent ID rule
On Wednesday, October 14, a three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ordered a preliminary injunction blocking California from enforcing the identification provision of its No Vigilantes Act, which required federal immigration and law enforcement officers to display identification while on duty in the state.
The panel — Judges Mark Bennett and Daniel Collins, both Trump appointees, and Judge Jacqueline Nguyen, an Obama appointee — ruled unanimously and reversed a lower court that had refused to block the law.
Judge Bennett wrote that the Act "attempts to directly regulate the United States in its performance of governmental functions" and that no set of circumstances exists under which it would be valid.
Why the unanimity is surprising
The ruling is notable because the Ninth Circuit has a reputation as a more liberal federal appeals court, yet the panel agreed unanimously against California — and went beyond the usual standard for preliminary injunctions.
Rather than finding the federal government merely likely to prevail, the judges declared the government "certain" to succeed in its constitutional challenge, according to MEAWW News.
The court held that because law enforcement is a core government function, the ID mandate is invalid in every instance it applies to federal officers acting under federal authority, and that even limited interference is impermissible when a state directly controls federal actions.
The legal reasoning: Supremacy Clause and intergovernmental immunity
The panel found that Section 10 of the No Vigilantes Act conflicts with the Constitution's Supremacy Clause and is barred by intergovernmental immunity, which prohibits state laws that regulate or discriminate against the federal government.
The judges wrote that the Supremacy Clause prohibits states from directly regulating federal operations even when state operations are regulated in the same manner, and that a state law directly regulating federal governmental conduct without congressional authorization is void regardless of how essential the regulated activities are or how much it interferes with federal operations.
The road to Wednesday's ruling
California Governor Gavin Newsom signed the No Vigilantes Act in September 2025 alongside the No Secret Police Act, which barred federal agents from wearing masks, responding to immigration sweeps carried out by masked agents in unmarked vehicles.
The Justice Department sued California, Newsom, and Attorney General Rob Bonta on November 17, 2025, before the law's January 2026 effective date.
In February, Judge Christina Snyder blocked the mask law but let the ID requirement proceed, agreeing it was more akin to a speed limit than a direct federal regulation.
In April, the appeals panel temporarily suspended the ID requirement, and Wednesday's ruling addressed the constitutional question more fully.
The stakes for transparency and accountability
Newsom criticized federal agents at signing time for arresting U.S. citizens, concealing their identities, and undermining transparency, saying the only metric for Trump and Stephen Miller was mass arrests, detentions and removals even at the expense of Americans' constitutional rights, per the Washington Examiner.
California's attorney general's office had argued that proper law enforcement requires transparency and accountability, according to ua.news.
On the other side, Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward Jr. called the decision a "huge WIN" for protecting officer safety and enforcing immigration laws.
The ruling comes as immigration enforcement remains a potent election issue, with a Reuters/Ipsos poll from September showing more than 40% of Americans strongly disapprove of the president's immigration handling.
What comes next
The ruling does not end the lawsuit; it prevents California from enforcing the identification requirement against federal officers while the case continues, the Washington Examiner reports.
California's remaining options are narrowing to seeking a rehearing or petitioning the Supreme Court, according to MEAWW News, and similar clashes between the administration and California have continued in federal courts during Trump's second term.
Sources
- latimes.com › California's 'No Vigilantes Act' requiring ID from immigration agents blocked by 9th Circuit
- news.meaww.com › Federal appeals court sides with Trump, blocks California law requiring federal agents to show ID
- ntd.com › Appeals Court Blocks California Law Requiring Federal Agents to Identify Themselves
- ua.news › US court blocks California ICE ID requirement — The Hill
- washingtonexaminer.com › Court bars California law requiring ICE officers to wear visible identification
- news.bloomberglaw.com › California's Federal Agent ID Law Halted by Ninth Circuit (1)