NHTSA Probes Comma's DIY Self-Driving Kit After Fatal Crashes
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Automotive
- Autonomous Driving
The NHTSA opened an investigation into Comma AI's Openpilot kits after five crashes that killed three people, all striking vehicles in-lane.
What Happened
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's Office of Defects Investigation has opened a probe into Comma AI's aftermarket self-driving hardware, which retrofits more than 350 vehicle models from 27 automakers with lane centering, adaptive cruise control and automatic lane changes.
According to the agency, it is aware of five crashes involving Comma three, Comma 3X, Comma four and Openpilot software, where vehicles reportedly struck stopped or slowly moving vehicles within the same travel lane.
One incident reportedly saw a vehicle using comma.ai products hit a first responder's vehicle, killing three people. The investigation covers roughly 30,000 hardware kits, a figure both TechRadar and Futurism report, and Futurism adds that eleven people were injured across the incidents.
Why It Is Surprising
The surprise here is that federal scrutiny has reached a hobbyist-adjacent product rather than an automaker's certified system.
TechRadar's own reviewer found the kit compelling enough to cancel Ford's $500-a-year BlueCruise subscription after driving over 1,000 miles with it, yet felt uneasy about "random people on the internet" writing car-controlling software.
The pushback went further when a video of a Tesla Model Y running Comma Four with "Sunnypilot," a community fork of Openpilot, alarmed observers. As writer Cairo Smith put it, "It is not Skyrim for Linux. You do not get mods on the freeway."
The Evidence Regulators Will Examine
NHTSA's Office of Defects Investigation stated plainly what it wants: "The investigation will obtain data to verify system status for each incident and evaluate system performance and safeguards that are intended to ensure safe operation of vehicles equipped with comma devices."
In every reported crash, vehicles running Openpilot slammed into slow-moving or stopped vehicles in their own lane — a consistent failure pattern rather than scattered incidents.
Futurism also reports that regulators are zeroing in on Comma's marketing, which promises "hands free driving for the car you already have" while the fine print says the car requires constant supervision.
TechRadar likewise notes Comma's homepage makes no clear mention anywhere that the driver must remain in control.
The Stakes
More than 30,000 drivers are running Openpilot, and the company claims over 402 million miles (650 million km) driven on the software, so any recall or forced safeguard would touch a substantial installed base.
The deeper stakes are cultural: TechRadar argues the US has a worrying trend of over-reliance on autonomy, citing an NBC News investigation that surfaced 43 social media videos apparently showing Tesla drivers distracted or even asleep while Full Self-Driving was active.
Futurism raises an additional layer — many users may not run stock software at all but modded forks, and AI-assisted coding raises the chance that someone inexperienced could customize Openpilot themselves, all without the accountability of a large commercial entity like Tesla.
What Comes Next
The immediate question is whether NHTSA's findings lead to a recall of the roughly 30,000 kits or a forced reworking of Comma's driver-monitoring safeguards and marketing language.
Until the investigation concludes, the ecosystem continues to grow — TechRadar notes Openpilot began with only a handful of Acura and Honda models and now spans more than 350 models thanks to community-coded software.
Futurism's framing is blunt: barring major regulatory intervention, we may have to get used to sharing the road with people's homemade robot chauffeurs.