Even Newsmax Legal Analysts Doubt DOJ's Network Probe

Two legal analysts on Newsmax, normally pro-Trump, say the DOJ's Sherman Act probe of five TV networks over the pool boycott is probably not a case.

@sharedot

Even Newsmax Legal Analysts Doubt DOJ's Network Probe

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Television
  • Press Freedom
  • Antitrust
  • White House

Two legal analysts on Newsmax, normally pro-Trump, say the DOJ's Sherman Act probe of five TV networks over the pool boycott is probably not a case.

What Happened: A Sherman Act Probe of the Pool

The Justice Department has opened an antitrust investigation into ABC News, CBS News, CNN, Fox News and NBC, the five broadcasters who make up the White House television press pool, according to NPR and ADWEEK.

The networks collectively suspended pool coverage after the administration barred CNN, MS NOW and Politico from the White House in September.

A DOJ spokesperson, Emily Covington, said members of the television press pool have "proudly boycotted covering White House events" and warned that group boycotts among commercial competitors can violate the Sherman Act. The networks learned of the investigation on Oct.

Why It Is Surprising: Newsmax Pushes Back

The most striking reaction came not from liberal media critics but from inside a conservative channel. According to PYMNTS and AOL (citing Mediaite's reporting), former judge Andrew Napolitano and trial attorney Wendy Patrick questioned the investigation on Newsmax's 'Bianca Across the Nation.'

Asked whether the conduct was an antitrust violation, Patrick answered, "Probably not," saying the facts are not clear-cut in the way other antitrust cases are.

The criticism landed precisely because Newsmax is a broadcaster generally associated with pro-Trump commentary, and even its legal panel saw no obvious case against the networks' solidarity action.

The Evidence: Political Purpose, Not Commercial

Napolitano argued that the five networks' combination was not for a commercial purpose but a political one, and that the Sherman Act "doesn't really pertain to the First Amendment."

He told host Bianca de la Garza that the press enjoys a unique protection: "the government can't apply ordinary laws to us if they interfere with the freedom of speech." PYMNTS notes these assessments are not a court ruling and do not establish whether the DOJ could ultimately succeed.

The Backdrop: A Ban, a Boycott, a Boycott Reversed

NPR reports the dispute began in mid-September when the administration banned CNN, MS NOW and Politico over coverage Trump called "purposefully negative." The TV pool partners agreed not to backfill for CNN on its assigned pool days — they said they would not "take CNN's place."

The networks later softened their stance, per NPR, and normal pool operations have since resumed, according to azat.tv, which notes CNN and Politico still remain barred from the Oval Office and from traveling aboard Air Force One despite a temporary restraining order restoring their credentials.

The Stakes: Access Litigation Converges

The probe lands alongside an ongoing First Amendment lawsuit. A federal judge has already leaned against the administration's ban, NPR says, and per azat.tv the temporary restraining order runs through Tuesday, Oct.

The antitrust inquiry is likely to become part of that case before the ruling, NPR's David Folkenflik suggested, and the pool's decades-old cooperative structure — broadcasters sharing footage with C-SPAN and hundreds of subscribers — is itself now under legal scrutiny.

What Comes Next: An Unprecedented Escalation

NPR frames the investigation as one prong in a broader, multipronged effort against the press — lawsuits against major networks, a broadcast regulator investigating broadcasters, DOJ pursuit of reporters' sources and devices, and cut funding for public media.

Press freedom advocates call it an unprecedented escalation of government pressure on independent media, per azat.tv.

Representatives for ABC News said they had not yet received formal notification but anticipated one, azat.tv reports, while NBC, CBS and CNN declined comment and Fox News and the White House did not respond.

For television viewers, the fight over who covers the president will escalate this week in a federal courtroom.

Sources

  1. npr.org › DOJ launches antitrust probe into TV networks over suspended pool coverage
  2. adweek.com › DOJ Launches Antitrust Investigation Against ABC News, CBS News, NBC News, CNN, and Fox News
  3. islamtimes.com › US DOJ Probes Five TV Networks Over White House Press Pool Boycott
  4. pymnts.com › Newsmax Legal Analysts Push Back on Trump DOJ's Antitrust Probe of TV Networks
  5. aol.com › Newsmax Legal Panel Pours Cold Water on Trump DOJ Antitrust Probe of TV Networks
  6. azat.tv › Justice Department Opens Antitrust Probe Into Major TV Networks Over White House Pool Suspension

More on Television