Critics Pan Ben Shapiro's Stalinist Drama 'Confession'
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Film
- Confession
- Ben Shapiro
- Movie Reviews
- Daily Wire
Critics pan Daily Wire's Stalinist prison drama 'Confession' as talky, sluggish and more sermon than cinema.
What Happened: A One-Night Theatrical Gamble
The Daily Wire released 'Confession,' a Stalinist Russia prison drama scripted by Ben Shapiro and directed by Václav Marhoul, with a one-night theatrical release on November 11 that coincided with its debut on the company's streaming service, according to The Hollywood Reporter.
UnHerd reports the film screened in 100 cinemas open exclusively to paying Daily Wire members, accompanied by a live chat in which Shapiro himself responded to complaints of tedium with the line, 'It turns out prison is… slow.'
Rob Lowe stars as Alexei, a former literature professor arrested in 1938 Moscow and interrogated at Lubyanka Prison by James Franco's Vladimir, a former prize student, with a cast that also includes Jennifer Jason Leigh, Nick Nolte, Emile Hirsch, Brad Dourif, Dean Norris and Kodi Smit-McPhee.
Why It Is Surprising: The Reviews Converged
What makes the rollout notable is how uniformly the early reviews landed, regardless of each outlet's vantage point. The Hollywood Reporter's critic, who openly states he finds Shapiro's politics loathsome, stresses that the pan is not ideological: the film is simply 'a dull, turgid slog.'
Variety, while crediting Rob Lowe and James Franco with 'credible and creditable' work and some 'potent emotional sparks,' still calls the drama 'sluggishly talky' and 'tough going.'
UnHerd's Ryan Zickgraf delivers the bluntest verdict of all, writing that 'Confession' is 'all meaning and content, and no movie.'
For a release framed by Shapiro himself, per UnHerd, as proof that 'with our new movie, Confession, we're winning' the cinematic culture wars, the near-consensus negative reception is a stinging result.
The Evidence: A Stagebound, 132-Minute Slog
The critics' specific complaints are remarkably consistent.
Both The Hollywood Reporter and Variety describe a film essentially confined to an interrogation room and a shared prison cell, so claustrophobic and fade-to-black structure that Variety says it 'plays like an adaptation of a stage play' nobody opened up for the screen, complete with what The Hollywood Reporter calls 'automaton' guards.
UnHerd notes Shapiro claims to have written the screenplay in four days, a fact the columnist suggests 'accidentally sounds like a confession of its own.'
The Hollywood Reporter says the endless literary name-dropping of Dostoevsky, Pushkin and Tolstoy invites a drinking game, while UnHerd jokes viewers are the ones getting 'crime and punishment.'
UnHerd also flags unintentional comedy: Franco bellowing 'Monsters change history!' in a flat California cadence, and no cast member attempting a Russian accent.
The Dissent: Sparks and a Late Reveal
Variety does offer the friendliest read of the pack, writing that Lowe and Franco 'do a credible and creditable job of inhabiting their characters' and strike emotional sparks even in stilted dialogue like 'Evil and good are luxuries the Revolution can no longer afford' — a line The Hollywood Reporter separately singles out as ham-fisted.
Variety also credits the film with tricks beyond its predictable plot: the connection between interrogator and prisoner is not mere screenwriter's contrivance, with a key chapter of shared history revealed only late in the story, plus an ambiguous conclusion about Alexei's sense that he deserves punishment for his sins that 'might cue lively discussion' among viewers who stay to the end.
Even UnHerd concedes Shapiro 'gives his villain actual arguments,' though buried in what the columnist calls stilted, amateurish dialogue.
The Stakes: Can the Right Make Art?
For the Daily Wire, the film is a deliberate provocation and a test case. UnHerd reports Shapiro framed the project as a new front in the cinematic culture wars, contrasting it with Netflix's glam-rock 'Narnia' and claiming the Right is 'winning' with this movie.
UnHerd also suggests the casting of James Franco, like Jonathan Majors in the company's recent 'Run Hide Fight: Infidels,' reads as a middle finger to Hollywood studios — a motive The Hollywood Reporter independently floats.
The coup was securing real actors and a prestigious director whose 2019 film 'The Painted Bird' prompted walkouts at Toronto and Venice, per The Hollywood Reporter and UnHerd.
Instead, UnHerd concludes the film 'apes prestige cinema just closely enough to land in the uncanny valley': 35mm grain, deep shadows and Oscar nominees, all slightly off.
What Comes Next: Streaming, Not Awards
There is no sign of a critical rebound. With the single theatrical night over, the film now lives on the Daily Wire's streaming service, where UnHerd notes Shapiro can dismiss tedium as the nature of prison itself.
Variety predicts the ambiguous final minutes might cue lively discussion among those who stick around, but nothing in the pack suggests awards campaigns or a wider rollout.
The picture that emerges is of a niche political media company making films for its own members — UnHerd notes the cinemas were open exclusively to paying Daily Wire subscribers — rather than crossing over.
For film watchers, the post-mortem question the pack leaves hanging is whether the interesting story is the movie at all: The Hollywood Reporter writes that the story behind landing such a cast 'would likely prove more interesting than the film itself.'
Sources
- hollywoodreporter.com › 'Confession' Review: Rob Lowe and James Franco in a Ben Shapiro-Scripted, Stalinist Russia-Set Drama That's Terminally Tedious
- unherd.com › Ben Shapiro's new film is more sermon than cinema
- variety.com › 'Confession' Review: Rob Lowe and James Franco Add Some Spark to Václav Marhoul's Deliberately Paced, Sluggishly Talky Drama