Fifth Circuit Rules ICE Can Hold Immigrants Without Bond
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- US News
- Immigration
- Fifth Circuit
- Ice Detention
A divided federal appeals court ruled ICE can detain immigrants who entered illegally without bond hearings through deportation proceedings.
What the court decided
In a 10-7 ruling issued Friday, the full Fifth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans held that immigrants who entered the country illegally have no right to seek bond while in custody during deportation proceedings — even if they have lived in the U.S. for years and lack a criminal history.
Trump-appointed Judge Cory Wilson wrote that such immigrants, having never been legally admitted, are entitled only to whatever rights Congress has spelled out in immigration law, and that they can secure release 'at any moment by agreeing to leave the country.'
The decision establishes binding precedent in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi.
Why the 10-7 outcome is surprising
The ruling reversed an earlier three-judge panel decision from July, which had upheld district court orders requiring immigration authorities to provide bond hearings within 90 days.
Federal district judges had found that holding the three men at the center of the case without any chance at bond violated due process.
Judge Andrew Oldham's concurrence went further, saying legally unadmitted immigrants receive 'exactly the same due process rights' they would have had at a port of entry — whatever rights Congress chooses to give them.
Homeland Security lawyer James Percival celebrated it on social media as a 'big win' on mandatory detention, calling it a principle codified in 1996 legislation but ignored for decades.
The three long-term residents at the center
The case stems from the arrests of three men by Texas state troopers during routine traffic stops between November 2025 and February 2026, who then turned them over to ICE.
According to Law Commentary, Ignacio Sosnava Rodriguez, a Mexican national, had lived in the country for more than 22 years before his December 2025 arrest, while Alejandro Villegas Angel, also from Mexico, had lived in the U.S. since 2011 and has two American-born children.
Miguel Angel Gomez Alvarado, a Honduran national who entered in 2012, has a U.S. citizen child. All three were eventually released after district judges found their detention without bond hearings unconstitutional; the Trump administration then appealed.
The stakes: due process and the dissent
Judge Leslie Southwick, a George W. Bush appointee, wrote in dissent that the ruling created an 'impenetrable wall between the Constitution and these long-term residents,' and Judge Dana Douglas separately warned the majority's reasoning gave immigration authorities sweeping detention powers without adequate judicial safeguards.
Rebecca Cassler of the American Immigration Council, who argued the case, said the right to due process is now 'hollow' for immigrants in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, and warned that the logic of the decision threatens everyone in the country.
Attorney Gracie Willis of the National Immigration Project called the ruling an affront to due process and said the public should be concerned the government can hold people indefinitely without justification.
The broader courtroom landscape
The ruling lands amid heavy legal resistance to the administration's July 2025 policy change, which extended mandatory detention to anyone arrested by ICE regardless of how long they had been in the country.
According to the Texas Tribune, more than 400 federal judges appointed by both parties have ruled in favor of immigrants' due process rights in more than 5,000 cases since that policy change, while 41 judges have sided with the administration in 250 cases.
ProPublica reports immigrants filed more than 89,000 habeas corpus petitions since January 2025 — more in the first 13 months of the second Trump administration than in the previous three administrations combined.
Politico data analysis shows the appeals have produced conflicting rulings across higher courts.
What comes next
The National Immigration Project is still assessing its legal options and has not decided whether to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, Willis said, and lawyers are watching how district courts react — many have previously ruled that detainees deserve bond unless they are a flight risk or danger.
Although Friday's ruling is limited to the Fifth Circuit, the administration has transferred many immigrants from other states to detention centers in Texas, widening its practical effect. The Supreme Court agreed earlier this month to hear Rhoney v.
Barbosa da Cunha, a related case over whether immigrants arrested inside the U.S. fall under Section 1225's mandatory detention or Section 1226's bond-hearing provisions, and its interpretation could reshape which detention rules apply nationwide.