Court: Constitution Doesn't Guarantee Clean Water
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- US News
- Courts
- Clean Water
- Mississippi
- Constitutional Law
The Fifth Circuit ruled the Constitution doesn't guarantee clean drinking water, tossing a Jackson, Mississippi lawsuit over lead-tainted tap water.
What the Fifth Circuit Decided
On September 4, 2026, the full Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, sitting en banc, upheld the dismissal of a 2022 lawsuit filed by Jackson residents Priscilla Sterling, Raine Becker, Shawn Miller and John Bennett.
The plaintiffs argued the city knowingly allowed lead into the drinking supply and then gave false assurances that the water was safe, violating their right to bodily integrity under the 14th Amendment's due process clause.
Judge Kurt Engelhardt, a Trump appointee, wrote for the 10-judge majority that while the deprivation of clean water was "grievous," it did "not infringe upon any deeply rooted constitutional right."
The court also held there is no constitutional right to truthful information from officials during a public health crisis, writing that "the Constitution does not provide redress for every governmental wrongdoing."
Why the Ruling Is a Reversal
The decision is a sharp reversal of course. A three-judge Fifth Circuit panel had revived the residents' claims in 2025, finding the allegations plausibly implicated their right to bodily autonomy, but the full court vacated that ruling and reheard the case en banc.
The outcome also broke with the expectations of plaintiffs' advocates because the majority acknowledged the city's conduct was serious yet still found no constitutional hook.
Bloomberg Law News reports that Clarence Webster III, the Jones Walker partner representing Jackson, called the decision "one of the most significant constitutional rulings the Fifth Circuit will issue this year."
The court's framing was narrow: the Constitution generally does not require municipalities to provide public services competently, and mismanaging a water system is "wholly different" from the forced surgeries and involuntary medicating where bodily-integrity rights have applied.
The Evidence Behind the Case
The lawsuit stemmed from Mississippi State Health Department testing conducted between 2010 and 2013 showing rising lead levels in Jackson's water.
The residents alleged the city knew by 2013 that low-pH water and a malfunctioning lime treatment system were allowing lead to leach from aging pipes, switched part of the city to more corrosive surface water, and withheld an EPA emergency order detailing violations.
Curtis treatment plant that left many residents without reliable tap water.
A Divided Court, A Stark Dissent
The 10-to-5 split produced a pointed partial dissent from Judge Catharina Haynes, a George W. Bush appointee, joined by the court's four liberal members.
Haynes argued that at this stage of litigation the well-pleaded allegations must be accepted as true and that the residents were at least entitled to discovery, calling their complaint a mirror of "one of the worst public health crises in recent American history — the Flint water crisis."
She said the Fifth Circuit "stands practically alone in its decades-long fence-sitting" on the state-created danger doctrine, which ten other circuits have adopted in some form, and she would have allowed claims against the city itself to proceed.
The New American reports that families of children who died in the Camp Mystic floods had urged the court to adopt that same doctrine.
The Stakes for Water Rights
The ruling sets binding precedent across the Fifth Circuit, which covers Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, meaning similar constitutional lawsuits over contaminated water are unlikely to succeed in that circuit's federal courts.
The decision arrived as the Trump administration works on regulations that Geo News reports would weaken Clean Water Act protections, sharpening fears among environmental advocates that courts and regulators are narrowing water safeguards simultaneously.
While no right to clean water exists in the U.S. Constitution or Mississippi's, states including California, Virginia, New York and Massachusetts have protected access to safe water in their own constitutions, and the United Nations recognized a human right to safe drinking water in 2010.
What Comes Next for Residents
The constitutional path is closed, but the majority pointed residents to alternatives: state tort claims, regulatory complaints, electing different representatives, and petitioning lawmakers for remedies.
Federal statutory claims, including under the Safe Drinking Water Act, remain available — the Justice Department filed its own civil complaint against Jackson in 2022 alleging Safe Drinking Water Act violations.
Jackson Mayor John Horhn welcomed the decision and said the city would continue working to improve its water system, according to Barlaman Today. The city has consistently denied the residents' allegations in court filings.
Sources
- usatoday.com › No constitutional right to clean water, federal court finds
- news.bloomberglaw.com › Constitution Doesn't Cover Right to Clean Water, Court Rules
- thenewamerican.com › 5th Circuit: No Constitutional Right to Clean Water or Truthful Officials
- geo.tv › Federal court rules: No constitutional right to clean water in landmark decision
- jp.ibtimes.com › Trump-appointed judge leads ruling that US Constitution guarantees no right to clean water
- barlamantoday.com › US Appeals Court Rejects Constitutional Right to Clean Water in Jackson Lead Case