Nintendo Wins $4.5M From Reddit Mod Who Never Showed Up
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Tech
- Gaming
- Nintendo
- Copyright
- Lawsuits
A Washington federal judge ordered Reddit moderator James 'Archbox' Williams to pay Nintendo $4.5 million in a default judgment over pirated Switch games.
What Happened
A Washington federal court has entered a $4.5 million default judgment in favor of Nintendo of America against James Williams, known online as 'Archbox,' ending a lawsuit first filed on June 28, 2024 in a Washington district court.
Nintendo accused Williams, reportedly a leading moderator of the r/SwitchPirates subreddit, of operating a network of online 'Pirate Shops' offering extensive libraries of pirated Switch games for free download, along with circumvention software.
Judge Lauren King wrote that Williams 'promoted online shops offering pirated Nintendo game files and circumvention software' even though he knew the activity violated copyright law. The judgment also orders Williams to immediately disable access to every shop he operates or controls.
Why the Default Win Was So Easy
The case ended by default because Williams never responded to the lawsuit in court, so Nintendo won the full amount it requested in its October 2025 motion, as Aftermath reports. The Verge reports Nintendo asked for the default judgment last October after Williams failed to answer the suit.
VGC adds that the court found Williams could not claim ignorance, since he had at one point hired a lawyer to object to a Google subpoena.
The Math: $150,000 Per Game
The $4.5 million award reflects $150,000 per violation across 30 copyrighted first-party games, including Animal Crossing: New Horizons, Luigi's Mansion 3, and Pikmin 4, The Verge reports.
That $150,000 figure is the maximum statutory damage allowed under US copyright law for willful infringement, per VGC, which says the judge agreed the request was 'not an unrealistic estimate' given that lost sales could have easily run into hundreds of thousands of dollars per game.
How Nintendo Found Archbox
In a detail several outlets found remarkable, Nintendo reportedly tracked Williams down through its own repair service.
According to Aftermath, citing a Game File report from November 2024, Nintendo identified Williams via Reddit, then linked that identity to a Nintendo account that had been used to request hardware repairs, giving the company his address.
The account reported that Nintendo shipped a repaired piece of hardware to that address just days before sending the cease-and-desist letter that led to the lawsuit.
TheGamer notes Williams allegedly left an obvious trail, moderating r/SwitchPirates while sending his own Switch to Nintendo for repairs under an account in his own name.
Part of a Wider Piracy Crackdown
The win is the latest in a flurry of Nintendo copyright actions. Earlier this month, a ruling from the District Court of The Hague in the Netherlands made it illegal to sell MIG flash cartridges that allow people to play pirated Switch copies, The Verge reports.
Nintendo also sued hardware seller Modded Hardware in June, per Aftermath.
What Comes Next
The injunction bars Williams from distributing pirated Nintendo games or circumvention software, and requires him to shut down his remaining online shops and any social media accounts used to distribute copyrighted Switch games, The Verge reports.
VGC notes the injunction also bans him from encouraging others to download pirated games. Collecting the money is a separate challenge: IGN observes that Nintendo 'just needs to track down Archbox and get him to pay,' given the defendant's refusal to engage with the case.
The r/SwitchPirates community itself has largely turned on him — Dexerto quotes commenters saying 'It takes a special kind of stupid to sell ROMs,' and the subreddit no longer lists him as a moderator, per Aftermath.
Sources
- theverge.com › Reddit mod ordered to pay Nintendo $4.5 million in Switch piracy lawsuit
- aftermath.site › Nintendo Wins $4.5M In Switch Pirate Lawsuit
- videogameschronicle.com › Court orders Reddit moderator who widely pirated Switch games to pay Nintendo $4.5 million in damages
- thegamer.com › Nintendo Wins Yet Another Multi-Million Dollar Switch Pirating Lawsuit
- ign.com › Nintendo Wins $4.5 Million From Reddit Mod Who Sold Pirated Switch Games