Half of Tracked Right Whales Took the Scenic Route
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Wildlife
- Southern Right Whales
- Whale Migration
- Satellite Tracking
A three-year satellite study of 21 southern right whales found half took indirect routes to feeding grounds, leaving early yet arriving on time.
Two routes, one arrival time
Scientists from the University of Auckland and international partners tracked 21 southern right whales over three years (2020–2022), following them from their winter breeding grounds at New Zealand's subantarctic Auckland Islands (Maungahuka) to feeding grounds south of Australia.
According to Discover Wildlife, which covered the study published in the journal Proceedings B, half the whales took a direct westward route while the other half headed further south before turning back north, tracing an L-shaped detour across the ocean.
Remarkably, both groups reached the feeding grounds at roughly the same time, coinciding with a peak in prey availability. The long-route whales simply left about a month earlier and travelled more slowly: the long trip averaged 64 days versus 42 for the direct one.
Why the detour is so surprising
Migration routes are usually assumed to be fixed, life-or-death corridors shaped by evolution, so finding a population split between two radically different strategies upends that assumption.
According to Discover Wildlife, lead author Leena Riekkola suggests the whales simply have different priorities: some are saving energy, others time.
Even more striking, departure time was the only significant predictor of which route a whale took — sex, body length, age and body condition showed no consistent link.
The study also documented one female making two different journeys: a route she took one year, then a different one the next when travelling alone.
That individual flexibility, University of Auckland associate professor Emma Carroll noted, means "a population that can adapt its behaviour has a better chance of coping with changing seas."
How the whales find their way
The tracked whales appeared to navigate using a mix of natural cues.
Discover Wildlife reports that whales on the L-route typically made their distinctive turn near the southern edge of the Antarctic Circumpolar Current, the huge current circling Antarctica, where the turn also coincided with a shallower seabed the whales appeared to follow.
The animals also seemed influenced by subtle variations in the Earth's magnetic field: most turns happened where magnetic inclination varied between -82° and -84°.
These cues may explain how whales on both routes consistently timed their arrivals to match peaks in prey availability south of Australia, despite taking paths thousands of kilometres apart in shape and duration.
Flexibility as a lifeline
The behavioural flexibility documented in the study carries real conservation weight.
Southern right whale populations are still recovering from historic commercial hunting, and Discover Wildlife notes that a female might delay migration and take the shorter route to let her calf grow bigger, then travel alone and choose the longer route the next year.
That ability to adjust strategy season to season could give the recovering population a potential leg up as climate change reshapes ocean conditions and prey distribution.
As a separate sign of how satellite tracking is opening up whale science, bioengineer.org reports the first satellite-telemetry records of minke whale movements off the US East Coast, showing foraging and migration patterns never before documented in those waters.