McRib Lawsuit Lives: Judge Refuses to Toss Rib-Meat Case
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Food
- Mcdonalds
- Mcrib
- Class Action Lawsuit
Fox Business reports a federal judge has ruled McDonald's must face a proposed class action claiming the McRib misleads customers about its meat.
What the ruling does — and doesn't — say
Fox Business reports that U.S. District Judge April Perry in Chicago ruled Friday that McDonald's must face a proposed class action accusing the chain of misleading customers about the meat in its McRib sandwich.
The judge rejected the company's bid to dismiss the lawsuit in its entirety, letting consumer deception, fraud and unjust enrichment claims proceed, while dismissing five other claims without prejudice.
Filed by four consumers in December, the suit alleges the McRib patty was designed to resemble a rack of pork ribs despite containing no actual rib meat.
Importantly, Fox Business notes the ruling allows the case to move forward but does not establish that McDonald's engaged in deceptive advertising.
Why a 'trademarked name' defense failed
According to Fox Business, McDonald's argued that the McRib's name cannot mislead reasonable consumers and that its publicly available ingredient list identifies pork as the primary ingredient.
Judge Perry rejected the claim that the trademarked name shields the company from deceptive marketing suits, pointing out that other McDonald's products — the McChicken and the Egg McMuffin among them — have names that describe what is actually inside.
The judge also found it too early to conclude that no reasonable consumer could expect the sandwich to contain rib meat, citing the plaintiffs' allegations about the sandwich's marketing and the survey evidence they submitted with the court filing.
The surveys and the meat allegations
Fox Business reports that one survey cited in the court filing found 72% of respondents expected the McRib to contain rib meat, while another found 67% considered rib meat important or very important to their purchasing decision.
The lawsuit, as Fox Business previously reported, alleges the patty contains lower-grade pork products — pork shoulder, heart, tripe and stomach — rather than rib meat.
McDonald's has denied the allegations, maintaining the sandwich is 100% pork sourced from U.S. farmers and suppliers, and the company told Fox Business it does not use heart, tripe or scalded stomach in the patty.
A McDonald's representative did not immediately respond to Fox Business's request for comment.
Stakes for the cult-favorite sandwich
The McRib, introduced in 1981, has built a devoted following through periodic limited-time returns, per Fox Business, and the boneless pork patty in barbecue sauce with onions and pickles is a fixture of fast-food lore.
For food fans following the case — and the Asbury Park Press video explainer asking what's actually in a McRib — the next phase will test whether marketing that evokes ribs crosses into deception, a question that could ripple across fast-food naming conventions far beyond one sandwich.